As anticipation builds for ‘The Batman – Part II’, a new rumor has sent DC fans into full detective mode. Sebastian Stan, the most recognizable face to the general public as the Winter Soldier in the Marvel universe, is also said to be circling a part in Matt Reeves‘ gritty Gotham saga.
Although DC Studios’ secrets, the internet buzz, and inside talk indicate that Stan is moving to the background as one of the most emotionally conflicted Batman villains.
Why Sebastian Stan’s Rumored DC Casting Feels Right For Gotham
The most interesting part of this rumor is not necessarily the casting, but the direction of the sequel. Instead of emphasizing spectacle, ‘The Batman – Part II’ seems to be willing to go all the way with psychological drama, moral ambiguity, and slow-burn character arcs. It’s a strategy that would suit Stan well as an actor. Should it be proven, Stan’s role may mark a tonal change in the franchise.
Related: Why James Gunn’s View Of ‘The Flash’ Feels Like A Course Correction For DC
There are rumors that Sebastian Stan might be Harvey Dent, the idealistic district attorney of Gotham who later turns out to be the notorious Two-Face. Although nothing has been officially confirmed, the idea itself has elicited a heated debate. Stan has made a career out of playing broken men who are struggling with their morality. Through his Bucky Barnes’ role, he had made it clear that he does not need to use big speeches or over-the-top theatrics to express inner conflict.
Such delicacy would be priceless for a Harvey Dent based on realism as opposed to comic-book bombast. Matt Reeves’ Gotham is not a place of bright costumes and villains. It is battered and corrupted. It’s a place where individuals don’t turn into monsters in one day, but they wear out over time. Interestingly, rumors also indicate that Scarlett Johansson, who has long been Stan’s MCU co-star, might feature in the sequel as Gilda Gold, Harvey Dent’s wife in DC Comics.
Neither of these casting rumors has been officially addressed by DC Studios. However, the symmetry of the possibilities has only continued to build up even more rumors. Notably, although Stan may be portraying Harvey Dent, it does not imply that the viewers would witness Two-Face appear right away. Reeves has been patient with character development, and it is perfectly possible that ‘The Batman -Part II’ would be laying the groundwork to a change that would be rewarded in a subsequent installment.
How Stan’s Casting Could Signal A Bigger Shift For The Franchise
In addition to the role, the rumored participation of Sebastian Stan suggests that there is something bigger going on behind the scenes of ‘The Batman -Part II’. Reeves’ universe is quietly becoming a magnet for prestige actors. Performers are drawn to it not by franchise longevity alone, but by the opportunity to explore psychologically rich material. The sequel will be set a little later than the happenings in ‘The Penguin’ Season 1. This will further solidify the idea of Gotham as a breathing, living ecosystem of crime.
In case you missed it: Before James Gunn’s DCU, ‘Green Lantern’ Had A Very Different Future At HBO
The interconnectedness of this corner of the DC universe is further confirmed by the return of Colin Farrell as Oz. In the meantime, Zoe Kravitz as Catwoman is said to be sitting out for this chapter. This implies a change in the storyline. It might lessen the romantic tension and focus more on institutional corruption. Joker, played by Barry Keoghan, is also reported to be back. However, Reeves has not been in a hurry to put the Clown Prince of Crime on the front burner. The same restraint might be applied to Harvey Dent.
Rather than instantly becoming Two-Face, the sequel can be about Harvey being the last great hope of lawful justice in Gotham City. And then it could focus on the gradual, agonizing understanding that the very system is flawed. Thematically, this would also be a reflection of Bruce Wayne’s journey. Both men would be trying to rescue Gotham, only to realize that being right is not enough. Moreover, casting an actor like Stan, who thrives in morally gray territory, would reinforce that parallel beautifully.
