There’s no denying that Robert Pattinson delivered a gripping performance in ‘The Batman’. His gloomy Dark Knight was raw, hurt, and felt very human. He immediately became one of the iconic live-action incarnations of Bruce Wayne to many fans.
However, as DC finds a new direction with a shared cinematic universe, the most intelligent thing to do is to leave Batman in his own down-to-earth world and create something completely new for the DCU.
Recasting Batman Isn’t A Risk, It’s DC’s Smartest Move
Pattinson’s Gotham is a gritty and realistic place. It is a place filled with serial killers, mob bosses, and systemic corruption. That tone works beautifully within director Matt Reeves’ contained trilogy vision. However, the DCU as envisioned by James Gunn is proving to be much larger in scale.
Related: How A Major DC Villain Shaped Tom Hiddleston’s Loki
It’s set in a universe that already encompasses super-powered characters, cosmic dangers, and increased comic book spectacle. Attempting to retrofit the hyper-realistic Caped Crusader into a world that includes Superman, Green Lantern, and mythical villains would be tonally dissonant. Even the introduction of elements like the Lazarus Pit or the League of Assassins might push the grounded aesthetic of Reeves to its limit.
Rather, Gunn’s ‘The Brave and the Bold’ provides a chance to accept a Batman that is made for a more fantastic world. Having confirmed the inclusion of Damian Wayne, the DCU is evidently making a move towards comic-faithful mythology early on. That in itself is an indicator that we might get another type of Dark Knight.
The Next Batman Must Be Built For Gods And Monsters
Batman’s recasting is not a denial of Pattinson’s success. It’s a strategic reset. Each period of DC has had the advantage of reinventing its icons to fit the universe at the time.
The new Batman will probably have to be experienced, a mentor to Damian, a peer to Superman. He also has to be someone who can fight monstrous villains like Clayface or Doctor Phosphorus. That leaves the door open for an actor capable of balancing gravitas and comic-book scale.
In case you missed it: Jensen Ackles Isn’t Letting Go Of His Batman Dream As The DCU Evolves
Brandon Sklenar, Glen Powell, and others have been mentioned in the fan discussions, and each of them can add a different energy to the role. Whoever ends up wearing the cowl will not only own Gotham, but a common universe that requires flexibility, leadership, and mythic presence. Pattinson’s Batman lives in darkness.
The DCU version might have to be taller, not only as a detective in the dark, but as a pillar in a world full of gods and monsters. And that evolution is exactly what this new chapter demands.
You might also like to read: Marvel Unites Two Of Its Most Powerful Villains For The First Time Ever
