The upcoming ‘Captain America: Brave New World’ is shrouded in mystery, and this time, it’s not about the villain’s identity. The controversy centers around Ruth Bat-Seraph, a character described as a “former Black Widow” turned “high-ranking U.S. government official.”
Additionally, fans were expecting her to be Sabra, a well-known Israeli superhero from the comics. Now, it seems Marvel might be taking the character in a whole new direction, and it’s sparking heated debates online.
Why Was A Change of Identity Needed?
For comic book readers, Sabra is a familiar face. She’s a mutant with superhuman strength, speed, and healing abilities, sworn to protect her homeland, Israel. Her codename, ‘Sabra,’ is a reference to the prickly pear cactus which is a symbol of native-born Israelis.
The announcement of Sabra’s inclusion in the MCU had mixed reactions. However, recent reports suggest a change of plans. The character description for Ruth Bat-Seraph doesn’t quite match Sabra’s comic book persona. Additionally, there’s no mention of mutant powers, and her Israeli connection seems downplayed.
This has some fans scratching their heads, while others are expressing outrage. Some Jewish outlets like Jewish Chronicles are outraged claiming that “Marvel stripped Jewish superhero Sabra of her Israeli identity”. So, Is Marvel whitewashing Sabra’s identity? Are they shying away from a potentially political character? Marvel is yet to comment.
In case you missed it: ‘Captain America: Brave New World’ Promo Art Reveals New Helmet For Captain America
Comic Book Sabra Vs ‘Captain America: Brave New World’ Sabra
Sabra’s name in the film is now Ruth Bat-Seraph, and details suggest a significant shift in her backstory. Gone are the mentions of mutant powers, replaced by the description of a “high-ranking U.S. government official.” Additionally, this downplayed Israeli connection and lack of mutant abilities have sparked concerns among fans.
Some fear a whitewashing of Sabra’s identity, while others worry about a potential shying away from the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in favor of a more generic portrayal. Moreover, the mystery surrounding Ruth Bat-Seraph’s true role in the film only deepens with reports suggesting a past as a “former Black Widow.”
This is a complete departure from the comic book Sabra, who served as an agent for Mossad, the Israeli intelligence agency. Whether these changes signify a more nuanced exploration of her character or a missed opportunity to represent a unique hero with a rich cultural background remains to be seen.
You might like to read:
