There are pivotal moments in comic book history, turning points that not only shock the readers but also forever change the characters, plots, and even the creative direction of whole franchises. In the case of Daredevil, this came in Daredevil #181 (1982) when Elektra Natchios was savagely killed by Bullseye.
Even today, the scene remains legendary. It’s cited in retrospectives, analyzed in documentaries, and etched into the emotional memory of Marvel fans everywhere. However, what most readers are not aware of is this: Elektra nearly did not die. Marvel feared losing her. She was too well-liked and beloved. So, a single dangerous creative choice, approved by one editor, not only transformed the story of Daredevil but the future of Marvel Comics.
Why Frank Miller Wanted Elektra To Die
It’s easy to look back now and think Elektra’s death was inevitable, part of the carefully plotted Daredevil epic Frank Miller was crafting. However, at the time, it was anything but guaranteed. Miller eventually disclosed the backstage battle at San Diego Comic-Con 2025. His editor, Denny O’Neil, dismissed the idea at once. He was worried that the editor-in-chief of Marvel, Jim Shooter, would never permit the company to kill one of its most popular rising characters.
Related: Krysten Ritter’s Jessica Jones To Rejoin MCU In A Major Way In ‘Daredevil: Born Again’ Season 2
Elektra was not a side character in Marvel. She was a sales phenomenon. The concern was blunt: “She’s more popular than Daredevil.” That wasn’t hyperbole. Elektra was the star of the book. Fans adored her. She boosted sales. Sox murdering her appeared to be commercial suicide. However, Miller was not writing a brand mascot. He was writing a tragedy. He walked directly into Jim Shooter’s office and told him why Elektra had to die. It was not to shock the readers or make noise.
He wanted to ensure that she was not turned into a hollow, repetitive version of herself. Without sacrifice, she risked becoming a caricature rather than a character. To everyone’s surprise, Shooter listened. He reflected. And then, in the most casual of phrases, “Tell me a story, Frank,” he opened the door to one of comics’ most important moments. Miller told him the ending. Shooter accepted it at the moment. And that was the turning point of comic book history.
Elektra’s Death Put Daredevil On Another Level
When Elektra’s blood stained the pages of Daredevil #181, the impact was seismic. This was not a mere shocking twist. It was an emotional earthquake that changed three characters permanently. Matt Murdock became permanently wounded. Matt had been living a miserable life even before the death of Elektra. However, her murder struck otherwise. She was not merely a lover, but a portion of his soul. She was his hope, his possibility of redemption, and his reminder that there could be light and darkness together.
In case you missed it: Charlie Cox Opens Up About Daredevil’s Return To MCU After Legal Issues
Her death shattered something in him. It was not a dramatic outburst of grief, but a gradual collapse. His faith wavered. His moral clarity blurred. And his faith in his cause was broken. This tragedy not only hurt Matt, but it also changed him. Many of Daredevil’s most powerful stories, including ‘Born Again’, only resonate because Elektra’s death exposed the fragile man beneath the mask.
Elektra’s death also turned Bullseye from a mere villain to a monster. Bullseye was never a harmless villain. However, Elektra’s murder made him one of the villains of the upper tier of Marvel. It was not merely an act of violence but an act of hatred, jealousy, and sadistic pride. Killing Elektra was his attempt to regain relevance after Daredevil humiliated him. A single scene made him a villain who even scares Daredevil.
