For decades, Spider-Man has been celebrated as one of Marvel’s most resilient and hopeful heroes. Peter Parker’s bright red-and-blue costume and relentless optimism made him a fan favorite across generations.
However, Marvel has just confirmed a revelation that casts a permanent shadow over the wall-crawler’s legacy: Spider-Man’s soul is doomed to eternal damnation in Hell.
Spider-Man’s Biggest Mistake Comes Back To Haunt Him In New Revelation

This fate stems from Peter’s infamous deal with Mephisto, Marvel’s devil-like entity, in the ‘One More Day’ storyline. Now, in ‘Bring on the Bad Guys: Mephisto #1′, it’s made official: anyone who bargains with Mephisto earns a reserved place in his fiery domain. And yes, that includes our beloved Peter Parker. Moreover, the seeds of Spider-Man’s tragic fate were sown years ago in ‘One More Day’. After Aunt May was fatally shot, Peter and Mary Jane struck a deal with Mephisto.
Related: Watch: Tom Holland’s ‘Spider-Man: Brand New Day’ Set Video Shows A First-Ever Marvel Moment
The deal had them sacrifice their marriage for May’s life to be spared. However, now we know that choice came with an even darker price tag. In ‘Bring on the Bad Guys: Mephisto #1’, Mephisto’s nature is made clear. Every deal he makes is a trap, every bargain a path toward eternal suffering. By signing away his marriage, Peter also signed away his soul. When he eventually dies, his afterlife won’t be one of peace, reunion, or rest. Instead, it will be eternal torment in Marvel’s version of Hell.
This revelation reframes Spider-Man’s entire journey. For years, he has been portrayed as a hero who finds hope even in the darkest times. Now, readers are faced with the reality that Peter’s endgame is the bleakest of all. His legacy ends with torture for a mistake he made out of love. It’s simply cruel. Yet, in true Marvel fashion, it also sets the stage for new storytelling opportunities. If Peter’s fate is sealed, the natural question becomes: can Spider-Man find a way to escape damnation?
Tobey Maguire’s ‘Spider-Man 2’ Suit Goes Up For Auction, Expected To Fetch Over $100,000

As Marvel darkens Spider-Man’s future on the comic page, fans have an opportunity to celebrate his cinematic past in a very real way. The iconic red-and-blue suit worn by Tobey Maguire in ‘Spider-Man 2’ is officially going up for auction, and it’s expected to fetch well over $100,000. The costume, designed by Frontline Design and Academy Award-winning designer James Acheson, was crafted specifically for the 2004 sequel.
In case you missed it: Mary Jane Watson’s New Arc Just Proved How She Doesn’t Need Spider-Man
The film is hailed as one of the greatest superhero movies ever made. ‘Spider-Man 2’ pushed Peter Parker to his emotional limits, exploring the burden of heroism, sacrifice, and identity. For many fans, this film established Spider-Man as one of the most beloved characters in pop culture. The suit itself is immaculate. It features a darker blue shade with muscle definition, smaller eye lenses, and a big chest emblem.
According to PropStore Auction, some parts of the costume suffered damage during filming but were later repaired. The starting bid is set at $50,000. However, experts predict it could soar as high as $200,000 given its rarity and cultural significance. And in a strangely poetic way, the auction arrives at the same time Marvel is writing Spider-Man’s darkest fate in the comics. It’s a reminder that while Peter Parker’s future may be filled with torment on the page, his legacy on the screen remains untouchable.