While ‘The Batman Part II’ slowly takes shape, speculation around its cast has become almost as intense as the anticipation for the film itself. As Matt Reeves carries on with his psychologically dense vision of Gotham City, each casting decision is subject to further examination. As soon as there were rumors that Sebastian Stan might appear in the sequel, perhaps as Harvey Dent, fans started to think about how well the MCU veteran would fit into the bleak noir world created by Reeves.
However, there is something more bittersweet beneath the surface-level excitement. There is one Batman villain who feels almost tailor-made for Sebastian Stan within Reeves’ Gotham, and yet, because of his defining Marvel role, it’s a casting choice that likely can’t happen. That villain is Hush, a character whose narrative DNA overlaps so closely with Stan’s Marvel legacy that it may forever keep him out of Bruce Wayne’s shadow.
Marvel Already Told the Story That Would Make Sebastian Stan’s Batman Villain Unavoidable
‘The Batman’ had already indicated in its opening scenes that Matt Reeves was not interested in the conventional superhero spectacle. This Gotham is a city that is decaying with inherited corruption, where wealth and privilege have silently destroyed generations of lives. Orphans, broken families, and moral rot are not side themes, but the basis. That is exactly why Hush seems to be such a natural progression of the sequel.
Related: ‘Avengers: Doomsday’s X-Men Teaser Revealed MCU’s Darkest Villains Yet
Hush in DC Comics is disclosed to be Bruce Wayne’s childhood friend, Thomas Elliot. Elliot was brought up rich, educated, and privileged, just like Bruce, on the surface. However, Bruce lost his parents in a tragic crime, and Thomas desired his parents to be dead. His resentment toward Bruce stems from the cruel irony that Thomas Wayne saved his mother’s life, delaying the inheritance Thomas believed he deserved.
This type of antagonist was already established in ‘The Batman’. The Riddler revealed the way the elite of Gotham cushioned themselves against the consequences, and left children vulnerable. Hush would be the ideal foil: a person born into privilege who still feels that he was victimized by the Waynes. The movie even flirted with his life.
The flashing HUSH message with imagery that was linked to the Elliot family was not a coincidence; it was almost like a promise. Hush would be the villain who attacks Bruce Wayne not through riddles or brute force, but through intimacy.
He knows Bruce. He understands his pain. And he weaponizes it. Here, Sebastian Stan fits in like a glove. Stan is about the same age as Robert Pattinson, has a similar brooding intensity, and even has some minor physical resemblances that can be useful in adapting Hush’s comic arc. More to the point, Stan is good at portraying men with broken identities.
In Fresh and Sharper, his acting revealed a disturbing duality, appealing to the eye, but hideous beneath. That duality is the essence of Hush. Thomas Elliot isn’t a cackling supervillain; he’s a mirror. A version of Bruce Wayne who chose resentment instead of purpose.
Sebastian Stan’s Marvel Shadow Makes It Impossible
And yet, for all the reasons Sebastian Stan would be ideal casting, there’s one overwhelming obstacle standing in the way: Bucky Barnes. Hush’s story is essentially based on Betrayal. He’s the hero’s childhood friend, presumed lost, who returns as a masked enemy shaped by trauma and obsession.
The same thing can be said about the Winter Soldier. The similarities are nearly unbelievable. Bucky Barnes was Steve Rogers’ best friend and was stronger and more confident even prior to the serum.
In case you missed it: Why MCU Treating Death Seriously Might Be Marvel’s Most Important Advantage
He vanishes, is assumed dead, and then returns as a villainized weapon, a darker version of Captain America. Hush adheres to the same emotional pattern as Batman. Even their thematic roles overlap. The two characters are symbolic of the question of what if.
What would have happened had Bruce Wayne directed his sorrow inwards? What would happen if Steve Rogers were unable to save the soul of his best friend?
Although viewers are becoming more open to the idea of actors switching between Marvel and DC, there is an unspoken rule of repetition. Crossing universes is fine. However, repeating character arcs is not.
Casting Sebastian Stan as Hush would risk feeling like a remix of Bucky Barnes rather than a fresh take, no matter how strong the performance.
