For almost twenty years, Spider-Man films have been playing with the same risky notion: more villains equals more fun. That gamble has backfired time and again.
From overcrowded third acts to rushed character arcs, the web-slinger’s cinematic history is littered with examples of “too much, too fast.” ‘Spider-Man: Brand New Day‘ is now ready to give that formula another trial. However, this time, it might actually have the right setup to pull it off.
‘Spider-Man: Brand New Day’ Crowded Rogues’ Gallery Could Actually Work
Spider-Man’s best movies have always been based on a single villain. Spider-Man 2 provided us with a well-developed Doctor Octopus. ‘Spider-Man: Homecoming’ gave the Vulture room to breathe. Even ‘Spider-Man: No Way Home’ intelligently designed its chaos so that Green Goblin ultimately carried the emotional weight.
Related: Marvel Is Delaying Tom Holland’s ‘Spider-Man: Brand New Day’ Trailer And We Know Why
However, when movies attempt to balance several villains that are fully developed, things fall apart. ‘Spider-Man 3’ is notorious for its inability to support Sandman, New Goblin, and Venom. ‘The Amazing Spider-Man 2’ tried to juggle Electro, Green Goblin, and Rhino, and failed to serve almost any of them.
It is not that a Sinister Six-style lineup cannot exist. It’s that every villain needs motivation, screen time, and thematic relevance. Without that balance, they become noise instead of narrative. And that is where ‘Brand New Day’ has a surprise advantage.
The Time Jump Can Be The Movie’s Secret Weapon
The key difference this time? The discontinuity between ‘Spider-Man: No Way Home’ and ‘Brand New Day’. As the world has forgotten Peter Parker since ‘No Way Home’s events, the new film places us in a New York where Peter has been working alone for a long enough time. That paves the way to something clever: villains who do not require complete origin stories since Peter has already taken care of them.
In case you missed it: Marvel Reopens Spider-Man’s Most Controversial Chapter With ‘Brand New Day’
Characters such as Scorpion, who were initially teased in ‘Homecoming’, do not need to be expositioned heavily. Boomerang or Tarantula as street-level threats can be used in quick-hit sequences that would set Peter’s routine instead of disrupting the narrative. Even Tombstone can serve as a high-level criminal presence rather than a late-stage surprise.
Provided that Marvel commits to montage storytelling and uses some of the villains for world-building instead of co-leads, the movie might not repeat the same errors. In place of six origin arcs competing to occupy space, we could have a single main antagonist with a plausible rogues’ gallery circling the city.
It is a high-flying balancing act. However, when done with caution, ‘Spider-Man: Brand New Day’ might be the first to demonstrate that a congested Spider-Man film does not necessarily fall under its own weight. Once again, villains may be, in fact, more world, not more chaos.
You might like to read: Spider-Man’s Live-Action Rulebook Gets Rewritten In 2026 By ‘Spider-Noir’
