Jack Nicholson became the biggest money-maker from ‘Batman‘ by taking a $4 million pay cut from his original offered price of $10 million by Warner Bros. Even though it surprised everyone back in the 80s, Nicholson clearly had a much bigger plan.
But ‘Batman‘ wasn’t seen as a sure hit back then. The movie looked risky, the casting caused outrage, and the whole project could have flopped. But Nicholson saw an opportunity that others didn’t, and that $4 million pay cut later turned into more than $90 million in income.
Jack Nicholson Declined The $10 Million Salary For ‘Batman’
Back in 1986, Warner Bros. was struggling to get Batman off the ground. Most people still associate Batman with the goofy 1960s TV show. Studio executives kept wondering why adults would even want to watch a movie about a guy dressed like a bat. Things didn’t get easier when Tim Burton came in. He had made ‘Pee-wee’s Big Adventure‘ and ‘Beetlejuice‘, which were creative and fun, but nothing close to a big superhero blockbuster.
Related: Shirley MacLaine Explains Why She And Jack Nicholson Never Dated
Then Warner Bros. cast Michael Keaton as Batman, and fans completely lost it. More than 50,000 people sent angry letters to the studio, upset that the ‘Mr. Mom‘ actor was supposed to play a dark superhero. So the studio turned to one person who could be the one and only situation: Jack Nicholson.
By then, he was Hollywood royalty. He had two Oscars and a long list of legendary movies, and his name alone made people feel like the movie was worth seeing. Warner Bros. told him straight up that they couldn’t make Batman without him and offered him $10 million. But Nicholson knew how to take advantage of the situation. So, Nicholson said he’d only take $6 million, but only if he could change how he got paid.
Nicholson asked for something almost no actor had at the time. He wanted a percentage of the movie’s gross box-office money, not just the studio’s profits. On top of that, he wanted a cut of every piece of Joker merchandise; toys, lunchboxes, T-shirts, Halloween costumes, cereal boxes, all of it. Warner Bros. had never agreed to something like that before, but they felt they had no choice.
Why Nicholson Was Willing to Take That Risk
Back in 1986, it was a huge gamble because no one knew if ‘Batman‘ would even work. Nicholson could have walked away with a guaranteed $10 million and zero stress. Instead, he bet that the movie would be massive and that people would go crazy for the Joker. That’s exactly what happened.
Batman made more than $400 million worldwide, and Joker merchandise took over stores everywhere. Nicholson reportedly got somewhere between 15 and 20 percent of the gross, and his biographer Mark Elliott later said his total earnings were close to $90 million, which would be almost $200 million today. Michael Keaton, the actual Batman, earned around $5 million, while Nicholson ended up making nearly twenty times more after taking a pay cut.
In case you missed it: How A Canceled 1990s ‘Bruce Wayne’ Series Could Have Changed Batman Forever
But this wasn’t new to Jack. Years earlier, he took a smaller salary plus 15 percent of the gross for One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, and when that movie became a huge hit, he made about $15 million. That deal taught him that studios usually underestimate how big a hit can become.
Besides the profit, Nicholson also had massive leverage because Warner Bros. had already admitted they needed him. He used that power to get more than just money. He got top billing, meaning his name appeared before Michael Keaton’s and even before the movie title. Nicholson had control over how his face was used in marketing, and he even had the filming schedule built around his Los Angeles Lakers games.
Jack Nicholson turned a $4 million pay cut into more than $90 million and made Hollywood look at money very differently from that day on.
You might also like to read: 10 Actors Who Admitted Signing Roles Just For Money
