The debate over where ‘The Hunger Games‘ really came from has suddenly returned, and it’s all because Quentin Tarantino has stepped forward with bold new claims.
He believes the blockbuster franchise didn’t just share similarities with another story; he thinks something much bigger happened behind the scenes. And his latest comments take the conversation in a direction fans may not expect.
Quentin Tarantino Calls Out the Major Overlap
Tarantino reopened the discussion on The Bret Easton Ellis Podcast, where he brought up the long-noticed overlap between ‘The Hunger Games‘ and the Japanese story Battle Royale. He pointed out that both feature teens forced into a deadly, government-controlled competition and said he couldn’t understand how Koushun Takami, who wrote the 1999 novel Battle Royale, never sued Suzanne Collins. He insisted on the podcast that Collins’ story “ripped off” the earlier one.
Related: Quentin Tarantino Delivers His Ultimate Vision With ‘Kill Bill: The Whole Bloody Affair’
Tarantino also reminded listeners that ‘Battle Royale‘ wasn’t just a book. It became a 2000 film directed by Kinji Fukasaku, a movie known for its shocking violence and the political controversy it sparked in Japan. To Tarantino, the idea that the two stories developed independently didn’t seem believable.
Suzanne Collins has addressed this before. In a 2011 interview with The New York Times, she said she had never heard of ‘Battle Royale‘ while writing her book. She recalled learning about it only after turning in the manuscript, and she said her editor advised her not to read it so she could stay focused on her own world.
Tarantino Says Critics Missed The Signs For Years
Tarantino called out the reviewers who praised ‘The Hunger Games‘ when the book came out in 2008. He said critics weren’t familiar with the Japanese movie, so they didn’t notice any similarities and even called the story “the most original” thing they had read. He said things changed quickly once the movie version of The Hunger Games premiered in 2012.
In case you missed it: Why Christopher Nolan And Quentin Tarantino Will Never Agree On Alfred Hitchcock
According to him, film critics immediately recognized the likeness to ‘Battle Royale‘ and complained that it felt like a toned-down version. He remembered how this reaction showed the comparison could no longer be ignored. EW critic Chris Nashawaty also compared both films at the time, recommending Battle Royale to viewers who wanted a darker, more violent version of a similar setup. Tarantino even mentioned a viral meme that same weekend.
Battle Royale’s own history helps explain why Tarantino’s comments hit so hard. The film received an R15+ rating in Japan for its graphic violence and faced heavy criticism from conservative politicians. But it still built a passionate fanbase, especially overseas.
