10 WWE Stars With the Most Premium Live Event Losses in History

John Cena and Kane

10- Rey Mysterio (72 Losses)

The masked luchador, Rey Mysterio, the "biggest little man" in sports entertainment, begins the top ten with 72 Premium Live Event defeats, a figure often attributed to his smaller size in a land of giants. Since his 2002 WWE debut, the two-time World Heavyweight Champion has competed in countless high-stakes matches. His legendary rivalry with Eddie Guerrero, which famously included a ladder match for the custody of his son Dominik at SummerSlam 2005, added to his count. His most consistent opponents in major events include Kurt Angle, Batista, Kane, and The Undertaker, demonstrating that Mysterio consistently faced and ultimately lost to many of the biggest names in WWE history.

9- John Cena (74 Losses)

With 74 PLE losses, John Cena's intermittent schedule since 2017 may have prevented him from ranking higher, but his 14 years as a full-time main eventer ensured a significant number of defeats. One of his most notable losses came in the first of his WrestleMania clashes against The Rock at WrestleMania 28. His career has been deeply intertwined with rival Randy Orton, who has accounted for many of his defeats on the grand stage. Additionally, he suffered a shocking sub-five-minute squash loss to The Undertaker at WrestleMania 34, contributing to the 17-time champion's substantial loss tally against contemporaries like Edge, Batista, and Shawn Michaels. Moreover, he also suffered a setback in his final PLE bout against Dominik Mysterio at Survivor Series 2025.

8- Kofi Kingston (78 Losses)

The 17-year veteran Kofi Kingston has suffered 78 losses on PPV, a total that is slightly mitigated by the fact that a significant portion of these shortcomings came in multi-man and tag team contests, owing to his long tenure with The New Day. Nevertheless, he has also faced his share of defeats in singles competition against Superstars like Randy Orton and Drew McIntyre. These numerous high-profile losses made his 2019 WrestleMania moment, where he defeated Daniel Bryan to capture the WWE Championship an extremely satisfying and long-awaited payoff, highlighting how his years of sacrifice and shortcomings ultimately made his biggest win all the more special.

7- Dolph Ziggler (82 Losses)

Dolph Ziggler, "The Show-Off," accumulated 82 losses, reflecting his long-standing role as a mid-card specialist who consistently appeared in championship rivalries at major events. He is often held in high regard as a PLE veteran due to his numerous appearances in matches for the United States or Intercontinental Championships. Though Ziggler ultimately came up short against major rivals like The Miz, Alberto Del Rio, and Seth Rollins on these paid stages, his dedication to the mid-card titles ensured his continuous inclusion in Premium Live Event programming, resulting in his high defeat total. This consistent presence underscores his career value, despite the high number of losses.

6- Triple H (83 Losses)

The Cerebral Assassin, Triple H, sits sixth with 83 losses, a number heavily influenced by his high-profile matchups, especially at WrestleMania, where he holds a negative 10-14 record. Three of his biggest defeats on the grandest stage were handed to him by The Undertaker. Despite becoming a 14-time World Champion, "The Game" competed in 105 title matches on PPVs, which provided ample opportunity for defeat. He lost to a host of other main-event stars, including Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins, Daniel Bryan, The Rock, and Batista, showcasing his willingness to compete against the company’s biggest stars at major Premium Live Events.

5- The Big Show (88 Losses)

The Big Show, also tallying 88 defeats across his 143 PPV/PLE appearances, was a force that commanded respect throughout his career, despite his negative win/loss record of 52 victories. His substantial loss count is attributed to facing opponents of the highest caliber, including Brock Lesnar, John Cena, The Undertaker, and Roman Reigns. Big Show's presence often involved him competing for championships or against main-event talent, which naturally led to many shortcomings against top-tier competition. While his losses were numerous, he can take pride in the fact that they came in significant matches against opponents who are all-time greats in the history of WWE.

4- Chris Jericho (88 Losses)

Tied for fourth place with 88 losses, the multi-time champion Chris Jericho has been involved in countless high-profile rivalries that culminated at major events. Throughout his illustrious career, he has suffered defeats against top-tier opponents such as Shawn Michaels, Edge, The Undertaker, John Cena, and Kevin Owens. Jericho competed in 43 championship matches on these grand stages, with 24 of his total defeats occurring in those crucial title tussles. Additionally, his negative 5-8 WrestleMania record adds to his overall count of Premium Live Event shortcomings, cementing his legacy as a performer who consistently faced the best, regardless of the outcome.

3- The Miz (97 Losses)

The Miz, a veteran since 2006, surprises many by ranking third with 97 defeats across 148 PLE matches. His high tally reflects years of being a consistent fixture on the card, particularly in the Intercontinental Championship scene, which he dominated for a considerable period. His most significant losses often came in high-stakes title defenses. For example, he lost the WWE Championship in a Steel Cage Triple Threat match to John Cena at Extreme Rules 2011. Similarly, The Miz dropped the Intercontinental title in a Triple Threat match against Seth Rollins at WrestleMania 34. His long tenure and consistent involvement in title pictures are the primary reasons for his substantial number of Premium Live Event defeats.

2- Randy Orton (108 Losses)

Given his status as a consistent, full-time competitor for over 23 years, it is unsurprising that Randy Orton sits high on this list with 108 losses accumulated across his career. The 14-time world champion has participated in over 170 PLE matches, including more than 40 main events, showcasing his longevity and presence at major shows. His list of conquerors reads like a "who's who" of legendary Superstars, including John Cena, The Undertaker, Daniel Bryan, and Brock Lesnar. Orton’s negative WrestleMania record of 8-11 further contributes significantly to his overall Premium Live Event loss tally, despite his immense success.

1- Kane (110 Losses)

The Big Red Machine tops the list with a staggering 110 defeats across 187 PPV/PLE matches, a testament to his lengthy and impactful career in WWE. A Hall of Famer, Kane's monumental loss tally is often intertwined with his storied rivalry against his kayfabe brother, The Undertaker, who holds a 2-1 advantage over him in their biggest Premium Live Event clashes. Though not always in the main event scene, Kane participated in a respectable number of title matches. His many conquerors, who tasted victory against him on the grandest stages, include Superstars with a strong claim to be on WWE's "Mount Rushmore," solidifying Kane's role as a legendary gatekeeper and formidable opponent throughout multiple eras.