James Gunn, who leads DC Studios and is shaping the new DC Universe, has spoken openly about why he sometimes casts non-white actors in roles that were originally written as white in comics, but not the other way around.
During recent casting discussions, the 59-year-old filmmaker responded to criticism about changes like those seen in ‘The Suicide Squad‘ and ‘Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3.’
James Gunn’s “95% White Superheroes” Argument
Gunn’s approach has led to strong reactions in Hollywood and among comic book fans, after he clearly explained his reasoning.
Related: 5 Superman Team-Ups We Want To See In James Gunn’s DCU
“That’s pretty simple,” he said. “Because 95% of all superheroes have historically been white it makes sense as we start adapting them to film in the modern era that some characters who were originally white become another ethnicity to more accurately reflect our world. In most cases, it would not make sense to take a character originally another ethnicity and make them white because there are already so many white superheroes.”
This idea about representation has become a key part of Gunn’s casting choices in both Marvel and DC projects.
Examples of Race-Swapping in James Gunn’s Films
Gunn’s approach is widely visible in his works. In ‘Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3,’ British actor Chukwudi Iwuji played the High Evolutionary, a character who was depicted as a white Englishman in the original comics. When some fans questioned the change, Gunn gave a direct answer, saying, “Because Chuk is the best actor I’ve ever worked with, that’s why. Has zero to do with race.”
In case you missed it: James Gunn’s DCU Quietly Confirmed Its First Two Justice League Members
He has also given similar answers in other cases, repeating that talent is the main reason behind his casting choices.
The same pattern shows up in his DC films. In last year’s ‘Superman‘ film, Wendell Pierce was cast as Perry White, who is usually shown as white in the comics. In ‘The Suicide Squad,’ Gunn was involved in changes around Deadshot, a white comic book character played by Will Smith and later introduced Bloodsport, another character originally penned as white, played by Idris Elba.
At the same time, none of the major non-white comic characters in Gunn’s projects have been changed to white, which keeps the debate around his casting choices going.
Ultimately, the debate around James Gunn’s casting choices reflects a broader tension in superhero adaptations today. As he works on his new DCU projects like ‘Creature Commandos‘ and ‘Superman: Man of Tomorrow,’ his approach continues to draw attention.
You might also like to read: Zack Snyder Applauds James Gunn’s Superman, Says DC Is In “Great Hands”
