For more than a decade, fantasy television has been chasing a shadow. That shadow is, of course, ‘Game of Thrones’, a show that was so successful that it not only conquered pop culture, but also reconfigured the way the industry believed fantasy was supposed to be. Political intrigue was obligatory, and cruelty was the order of the day.
And while some shows thrived under that template, many more felt like pale imitations, mistaking darkness for depth. HBO is now going back to Westeros again with ‘A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms’. And ironically, it is the project that might finally break the trap that ‘Game of Thrones’ has put fantasy TV in. Not by being bigger. Not by being bloodier. But smaller, warmer, more human.
Fantasy TV Needs A Smaller Westeros From ‘A Knight Of The Seven Kingdoms’
‘A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms’ stories by George R. R. Martin have never been similar to the rest of A Song of Ice and Fire. They are set in the same savage world, the same oppressive political regimes, but they are essentially different in their souls. It is that difference that makes them special. Dunk is not a king, general, or master strategist. He is tall, clumsy, poor, and always out of his depth. He is a believer in chivalry at a time when the world scoffs at the idea.
Related: ‘A Knight Of The Seven’ Kingdoms Finally Explores The Hidden Targaryen Era
Egg, meanwhile, is curious, stubborn, and secretly important, but defined more by his moral compass than his destiny. The two of them are like the characters of the old fantasy traditions: the wandering knight and his cunning squire. The contrast is what makes their story work. Westeros is inexorable. Knights still cheat. Nobles still abuse power. Violence continues to come unannounced and without any mercy. However, through Dunk’s eyes, the audience observes something different, faith, even when it is not convenient or safe.
According to initial trailers and descriptions, the HBO adaptation appears to know this balance. The show appears like a close-up instead of expansive. And it’s character-oriented instead of politically obsessed. No armies are fighting on the fields, no council rooms with whispering power brokers. Rather, it seems to be about the journey, about individual honor, about decisions that are important to the individuals who make them, even when the survival of the kingdom is not in question. That change in itself is refreshing. For years, fantasy television has treated emotional sincerity as a liability. ‘A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms’ appears ready to prove the opposite.
The Course Correction Is More Than Another Power Struggle
The problem with fantasy television today isn’t a lack of talent or budget; it’s creative uniformity. ‘Game of Thrones’ has led to too many shows thinking that fantasy has to be unrealistically grim to be taken seriously. Adventure is substituted with political intrigue. Cynicism replaces hope. And violence replaces wonder. That style is effective in some narratives. ‘House of the Dragon’, in particular, is successful as it goes all the way from dynastic tragedy to corruption.
In case you missed it: Who Is Prince Baelor Breakspear In ‘A Knight Of The Seven Kingdoms’?
However, not all fantasy stories should be about who is on the throne. The genre of fantasy was constructed around the theme of journeys, unrealistic heroes, and minor acts of bravery that spread out. It is here that ‘A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms’ may redefine the genre. It probably will not take over the number of viewers ‘Game of Thrones’ had, but that is alright. Its actual influence can be subtle. If audiences respond strongly to Dunk and Egg, it sends a powerful signal to the industry.
It informs creators and executives that fantasy does not have to be grim to work. Audiences still demand tales of honor, friendship, and decency even in violent worlds. That one swordfight with emotional interests can be more than a whole war of abstract power. It is also poetic that Westeros is spearheading this change. The world that made television fantasy believe that it should become harsher and colder can now assist it in finding warmth again.
