The return of ‘Dexter: Resurrection’ has breathed new life into one of television’s most complex antiheroes, Dexter Morgan. Besides this, it also rekindled old rivalries that fans never truly let go of. Among them, the tension between Dexter and Angel Batista has emerged as the most compelling storyline of the revival’s first season.
Unsurprisingly, their reunion was filled with unease, unspoken history, and the creeping inevitability of truth. For longtime fans, Batista’s pursuit of Dexter is more than just another cop chasing a suspect. It’s personal.
Batista And Dexter’s Reunion Was Decades In The Making
In ‘Dexter: Resurrection’, audiences finally witnessed Batista and Dexter engage in something close to an honest conversation. David Zayas, who has played Batista since the original Dexter run, explained in a SR interview that this encounter wasn’t about bravado or confrontation. Instead, it revealed Batista’s conflicted humanity.
Related: Dexter’s Return In ‘Dexter: Resurrection’ Overlooks A Key Part Of ‘Original Sin’
At first, Batista’s choice to greet Dexter with a casual “Surprise, hermano” might have seemed like a wink to James Doakes’ iconic “Surprise, motherf***er.” However, Zayas clarified that Batista’s delivery came from a place of restraint. He didn’t want to publicly expose Dexter in front of his family, knowing it would spark a dangerous confrontation. “I just basically did not want to expose him in front of this family because they might’ve created a bigger confrontation at that moment,” Zayas explained.
This hesitation isn’t a weakness. It’s a deliberate choice. After all, these two men have known each other for over 30 years, stretching back to ‘Original Sin’. They’ve celebrated life’s milestones together: weddings, family moments, personal struggles. To reconcile that history with the chilling truth that Dexter is the Bay Harbor Butcher requires more than just professional objectivity.
However, when the pair later shared a tense car ride, the gloves came off. It was the first time Batista came face to face with Dexter’s “dark passenger.” And Batista didn’t flinch. As Zayas put it, “Fear, even though it’s there, it’s not at the top of his list. He’s on a mission to seek justice.” That quiet determination makes Batista the most dangerous threat Dexter has faced in years.
David Zayas Claims Batista Is Not Going To Let Go Of Dexter’s Past
If episode 7 was about the emotional weight of their reunion, the following episodes promise to escalate Batista’s hunt. As revealed in his TVLine interview, Zayas emphasized that Batista simply cannot walk away. “If you think about Original Sin, Batista’s known this man for 30 years,” Zayas explained. “To find all that out now, all the truth, I don’t think somebody like Batista could let that go. Until the truth comes out. Until there’s justice to be had.”
In case you missed it: ‘Dexter: Resurrection’ Finds Debra Morgan’s Successor In Harrison
That obsession is on full display as Batista secretly plants his AirPods in Dexter’s car, turning them into a makeshift tracking device. It’s a risky move. However, it also speaks volumes about his desperation to catch Dexter red-handed. Unlike detectives Wallace and Oliva, who demand hard evidence before buying into Batista’s theory, Batista is driven by instinct and gut memory. He knows Dexter in ways few others do, and he’s willing to risk everything to prove it.
And that’s where the human drama intensifies. Batista understands the danger he’s courting. Dexter warned him outright: “This can’t possibly end well for you.” That wasn’t an idle threat; we’ve seen Dexter kill before to protect his identity, even violating his own code, like when he murdered Logan in ‘Dexter: New Blood’. If it comes down to survival, could Dexter kill Batista, too?
The answer isn’t simple. Unlike Logan or other collateral victims, Batista isn’t just another obstacle. He’s a friend. That’s what makes this looming showdown feel heavier than any Dexter storyline in years. Still, Zayas made it clear that Batista is ready to face whatever outcome awaits. “He understands that this may not end well for him, and I just think he’s past that,” the actor said. “There are some things that he can’t let go, and he’s got to try and do the right thing. And that leads to a lot of problems.”
