Parenting is never easy, and raising a child like Sheldon Cooper comes with its own set of unique challenges. Over the years, ‘The Big Bang Theory’ and its prequel ‘Young Sheldon’ have painted contrasting images of Mary Cooper. While she was often seen as a loving and religious mother in TBBT, ‘Young Sheldon’ shed new light on her parenting style.
The show made her a controversial figure among fans. Some argue she’s overly strict, dismissive, and even neglectful of her other children, while others defend her, pointing out the immense pressure she faced while raising an intellectually gifted but socially awkward son. However, was Mary really a bad mother?
Mary Was Often Seen Prioritizing Sheldon Over Her Other Children
It’s undeniable that Mary often prioritizes Sheldon’s needs over those of her other children. While it makes sense that a prodigy like Sheldon would require extra attention, the imbalance is stark. Georgie frequently feels overlooked, forced to fend for himself in ways a teenager shouldn’t have to. Missy also receives little attention compared to her brother.
Related: ‘The Big Bang Theory’: Why Everyone Put Up With Sheldon
Even in ‘The Big Bang Theory’, an adult Georgie expresses resentment toward the way their childhood played out. Mary’s favoritism, however, doesn’t stem from malice. In many ways, she’s trapped in an impossible situation. On one hand, she has an exceptionally gifted son who doesn’t fit in and struggles with basic social interactions.
On the other, she has two “regular” children who need love and support but don’t demand the same level of specialized care as Sheldon. This imbalance inevitably leads to tensions within the family. But does that make Mary a villain? Or does it make her a mother forced to make difficult choices.
Additionally, Mary is deeply influenced by her religious beliefs. Her faith provides structure in her life, but it also makes her inflexible at times. Her handling of Georgie’s teenage pregnancy situation in ‘Young Sheldon’ is a clear example. Rather than seeing it as an opportunity to support her son and soon-to-be grandchild, she initially reacts with frustration.
Mary Was Flawed But An Undeniably Devoted Mother
If one thing is clear, it’s that Mary loves her children. Her methods may be questionable but her devotion is always unwavering. Unlike her husband George, who is often painted as more relaxed and detached, Mary is the one constantly worrying, planning. She is always pushing her children toward what she believes is the right path. For Sheldon, this means endless encouragement in his academic pursuits.
She fights to get him into advanced classes, ensures he’s given the tools to excel, and fiercely defends him. But this also leads to excessive coddling. She excuses Sheldon’s often rude and self-centered behavior. It’s a classic case of overcompensation. She knows the world is tough, so she tries to shield him. However, this makes it harder for him to function in normal social settings.
Her relationships with Missy and Georgie are more strained, but not entirely without love. There are moments in ‘Young Sheldon’, where we see glimpses of Mary’s deep affection for her other children. Mary’s marriage to George also complicates her role as a mother. The prequel series paints a more sympathetic picture of George. It shows him as a hardworking man who, while flawed, isn’t the neglectful drunk Sheldon describes in TBBT.
Instead, Young Sheldon subtly hints that Mary’s unwavering religious devotion and emotional distance play a role in their marital struggles. She often dismisses George’s concerns, belittles his efforts, and seeks validation elsewhere. Whether intentional or not, her actions push George further away, setting up the inevitable fracture in their marriage.
Why Mary Deserves More Understanding
It’s easy to criticize Mary, but it’s important to view her through a compassionate lens. Parenting is difficult enough without the added stress of raising a genius, maintaining a household, dealing with personal insecurities, and failing marriage. ‘Young Sheldon’ does an excellent job of showing that Mary is not a saint, nor is she a villain.
In case you missed it: ‘Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage’: What To Expect from ‘Young Sheldon’ Spin-Off
Her story is one of sacrifice. She gave up personal aspirations to be a stay-at-home mom and devoted her life to faith because it provided the stability she lacked growing up. She put Sheldon’s needs first, not because she loved Missy and Georgie any less, but because she felt it was necessary for Sheldon to thrive. Her mistakes don’t erase her efforts.
