When ‘Modern Family‘ first aired on ABC in 2009, it revolutionized the sitcom landscape with relatable humor, lovable characters, and a fresh mockumentary-style approach. The show traces the connected lives of the Pritchett, Dunphy, and Tucker families as the diverse family dynamic interplays, creating quirky humor and tackling issues that often seem genuine but light-hearted. It won over the audience very fast, which meant that there was a great reception as well as massive popularity that led to the show’s longevity of an astonishing 11 seasons.
Throughout its decade on the air, the show ran and encompassed a blend of comedic misadventures, emotional moments involving family, and changes in relationships that each season created its own distinct memories. Yet, some seasons surpassed the others in truly defining the nature of the series. Modern Family had become something of a phenomenon with 250 episodes and 22 Emmy wins. Yet, some seasons reached better into the hearts of fans and critics. So let’s head down memory lane and check out all the seasons, ranked from those that showed hints of age to the unforgettable moments that defined this beloved series.
11. Season 9 – Struggling To Stay Fresh
Rating: 6.7/10 (IMDb)
Season 9 is where Modern Family started to get old. The show was trying too hard to come up with some new storylines for fans who were already familiar with the Pritchett-Dunphy clan. This season repeated storylines, such as their family Halloween episode and all things Phil, but there seemed to be less steam there. Although many fans loved it, the show did not stop making the critics feel a repetition; Variety stated that the show “seemed to be running in place.” Such standout episodes as “Ten Years Later” were still able to make it funny, but overall, the season lost that sense of originality that once made the series a breakthrough hit.
10. Season 10 – A Few Surprises, Lacking Impact
Rating: 6.9/10 (IMDb)
Season 10 tried to bring some refreshing changes as it zeroes in on what is new: Haley’s unwanted pregnancy, for example. Some critics and fans also felt that the show had lost its once-knock-out punch of laughter. The characters are as lovable as ever, but there’s a sense that they’re going through the motions, said The Hollywood Reporter. One bright spot was the episode “Good Grief,” which balanced comedy with poignancy as the family reacted to the loss of Jay’s ex-wife, DeDe. While the season had its moments, it failed to keep viewers as invested as in the show’s earlier years.
9. Season 8 – Familiar Ground Without New Punchlines
Rating: 7.1/10 (IMDb)
Season 8 of Modern Family stays faithful to its formula, delivering laughs but not with many surprises. Phil’s crazy schemes, Gloria’s fierce family loyalty, and Cam and Mitch’s parenting adventures keep the comedy intact, but it feels a bit too over-reliant on familiar ground. “The family dynamics are starting to feel more sitcom than real,” Collider noted, echoing a widespread sentiment that the show had lost its edge. Of course, episodes like “The Alliance,” in which various family members form unlikely teams, remind fans of what makes the characters so enjoyable. Not groundbreaking by any means, Season 8 still offers good fun, though it’s clear the show is starting to show its age.
8. Season 11 – A Bittersweet Goodbye
Rating: 7.2/10 (IMDb)
The final season of Modern Family takes the route of nostalgia as characters go about new chapters of their lives. With episodes like “Finale Part 1 & Part 2,” the season is full of goodbyes and resolutions for each family member, which is emotional, but not necessarily groundbreaking. Fans appreciated the nods to earlier seasons, though some felt the humor wasn’t as sharp. Quipped TV Guide said, “Season 11 feels like a farewell tour, hitting familiar beats but with an eye on closure.” It may not have reached the comedic heights of earlier years but it still did its part in wrapping the family’s story nicely in the last season.
In case you missed it: ‘Modern Family’ Star Julie Bowen Calls Out Press Attempts Of Pitting Her Against Sofia Vergara Like They Were Betty And Veronica
Season 7 – Relying On Old Tropes
Rating: 7.4/10 (IMDb).
Impressions of Phil, Gloria’s fiery temper, and Claire’s professional challenges keep the comedy fresh, but some of the plots are a bit unimaginative. The season deepens the dynamics of characters, such as Mitch and Cam trying to balance work and life, keeping the family very relatable even when the humor is not so new and different. As Entertainment Weekly summarized, “The show’s charm keeps it afloat, but it’s becoming clear that the formula is wearing thin.” Season 7 is entertaining, though it misses the creativity of the early seasons.
6. Season 6 – Funny But Familiar
Rating: 7.8/10 (IMDb)
Season 6 has the trademark humor and family drama of the show, but critics commented on a lack of development in some characters. Phil and Claire still encounter every aspect of parenthood while Gloria and Jay adapt to married life. Though it doesn’t break new ground, this season has stand-out episodes such as “Halloween 3: AwesomeLand” with the continued family antics during Halloween. It is predictable, yet warm and funny; therefore, Rolling Stone reports fans wanted more this season and they said “Season 6 isn’t revolutionary, but it’s still the show we love.”.
5. Season 5 – The Wedding And Big Changes
Rating: 8.0/10 (IMDb)
Season 5 marks a big change as it has the wedding of Mitch and Cam, an advanced storyline that proves how this show is willing to display families in a diversified fashion. It’s an evenly hilarious and emotional season that brings some fantastic scenes, leading up to the wedding, which was utterly chaotic. “Mitch and Cam’s wedding is a landmark for the show,” USA Today wrote, “showing Modern Family at its progressive best.” Season 5 brings together laugh-out-loud moments with heartfelt moments that solidify the season among the favorite ones from the series.
4. Season 4 – New Family Members, New Dynamics
Rating: 8.1/10 (IMDb)
Season 4 introduced Gloria’s pregnancy and the birth of baby Joe to bring new challenges and laughter to the Pritchett family. With episodes like “Fulgencio,” where Jay has become a father at an older age, the season shows growth within the family. This season also has great subplots, such as Phil’s run of projects and Haley’s teen spunk. Fans and critics alike praised the new vibes, with The Guardian calling it “a season of growth and fresh humor.” Season 4 is an emotional and comedic highlight in the series that truly stands out.
3. Season 2 – The Development Of Our Beloved Characters
Rating: 8.6/10 (IMDb)
Season 2 builds further on the hype generated during the first season. Characters are explored deeper into what makes them weird and even weirder. Classics start popping up like “Halloween” and “Strangers on a Treadmill,” cementing humor and relationships that the family carries over to the audience. Ty Burrell as Phil and Julie Bowen as Claire are great and give “a hilarious mix of heartfelt moments and laughs,” says The A.V. Club. Season 2 of Modern Family took its cultural influence to a whole new level by developing depth in characters and some of its most iconic episodes.
2. Season 1 – A Revolutionary Start
Rating: 8.7/10 (IMDb)
Season 1 introduced the Pritchett-Dunphy-Tucker family to viewers in a groundbreaking way. Using its mockumentary format, the season allowed Modern Family to stand out as a refreshing twist in the genre of family sitcoms. The episodes like “Fizbo” and “Run for Your Wife” are proof that Modern Family can beautifully interlink comedy with real family problems. “It was like nothing else on television,” the New York Times commented while lauding the heart and humor of the season. Original and funny, season 1 is probably the best season of the entire series.
Related: Why Did ‘Modern Family’ End After 11 Seasons? Was The Show Canceled?
1. Season 3 – The Best Modern Family Yet
Rating: 8.8/10 (IMDb)
Season 3 brings Modern Family to its creative and humorous peak. Its episodes, such as “Dude Ranch” and “Punkin Chunkin,” are unforgettable. This season of the family’s adventures and quirky dynamics can never be forgotten. It was the season that proved to critics and fans alike why Modern Family was such a hit. “A season where Modern Family found its sweet spot between laughter and depth.” It is the show’s strongest season in all aspects because it reveals all the quirks and growth of each character.
