To a large number of horror enthusiasts, Bill Skarsgard is Pennywise. His unnerving performance in ‘IT’ (2017) and ‘IT: Chapter Two’ (2019) redefined Stephen King’s shape-shifting monster for a new generation and instantly cemented Skarsgard as one of modern horror’s most unforgettable faces.
Therefore, when HBO announced ‘IT: Welcome to Derry’, a prequel series that explores the mythology of the creature in greater detail, it was only natural that Skarsgard would come back. Except, it almost didn’t happen.
Bill Skarsgard Feared Overexposure And “Milking” A Horror Icon
Although he later reverted to the red balloon-carrying danger, Skarsgard recently admitted that his initial response to the concept was not excitement, but hesitation. Speaking while promoting his crime biopic Dead Man’s Wire, the actor opened up about why returning to Pennywise felt like a risky proposition, and why it ultimately won him over. Skarsgard did not avoid it because he did not like Pennywise or the IT world.
Related: Why DC’s New Joker Makes Pennywise Look Almost Contained
Actually, he was concerned because of what the films had already accomplished. The two IT films were huge commercial hits and became cultural icons. To Skarsgard, that was what made the thought of carrying on with the story potentially dangerous. “We did the two movies, and they were very successful,” he explained. However, he was concerned that the franchise was being stretched beyond its natural boundaries.
The prospect of adapting Pennywise into a TV series brought up a crucial question for him: would the series enhance the mythology, or merely water down what made the character so successful? It is a fear that most actors keep to themselves, the fear of going back to a role that is already fully developed. Horror, especially, is a genre that feeds on mystery. Excessive exposure will make terror a household name, and Skarsgard did not want Pennywise to lose his edge.
That hesitation had a personal dimension as well. The success of IT as a breakout film gave Skarsgard a lot of opportunities. However, it also came with the danger of typecasting. The history of horror is full of actors who could not get rid of iconic roles. Pennywise boosted Skarsgard’s career. Repetitive appearances would have confined him to one character at a time when he wanted to venture into new creative frontiers.
Why Pennywise Still Has More To Offer
It was not pressure or obligation that finally made Skarsgard come back, but curiosity. Once Andy Muschietti laid out the creative vision for ‘IT: Welcome to Derry’, the actor realized the series wasn’t about repeating what audiences had already seen.
Rather, the show delved into untapped areas of Pennywise’s life, such as his feeding patterns, the ancient history of the creature, and more subtle details of his actions. For Skarsgard, it was a new emotional and psychological territory to be traversed.
In case you missed it: ‘IT’: The Deleted R-Rated Pennywise Scene Set In 1637, Explained
“There were parts of Pennywise we hadn’t seen before,” he said, describing the experience as creatively rewarding. Some of the scenes allowed him to experiment with various tinges of the character. Some scenes are not based on shock value or spectacle but on disturbing presence and silent threat. Reuniting with Muschietti also helped, as their long-standing creative chemistry made the return feel collaborative rather than obligatory.
