Episode 3 of ‘The Boys’ Season 5 just proved that Billy Butcher can never be saved. Butcher has been walking the fine line between an anti-hero who is ruthless and a monster. He has betrayed nearly everyone around him in his fight against Homelander.
However, with Ryan, there was always a flicker of something softer, something that felt like redemption might still be possible. This episode doesn’t just dim that hope. It virtually smothers it.
Butcher Crosses His Darkest Line Yet In ‘The Boys’ Season 5
The conversation between Butcher and Ryan is oddly quiet, honest, and even. No manipulation, no sugarcoating, the ugly truth. And that makes it worse somehow. Because what he’s really asking is unthinkable. He wants Ryan to be dead. Eric Kripke did not even attempt to make it soft. He referred to the incident as Butcher basically requesting a child to be a suicide bomber.
Related: Jessie T. Usher Calls His ‘The Boys’ Exit A “Perfect” Ending
“Yeah, I think he’s serious about it. I think that conversation he has with Ryan at the bar is chilling because it’s delivered with such warmth and sympathy, but he’s asking the kid to be a suicide bomber,” he told SR. And that is the way it plays. There’s warmth in Butcher’s voice, maybe even a hint of guilt. Yet, the request itself is cold and immovable.
That’s the shift. Old Butcher could have duped Ryan into assisting. This version doesn’t bother. He puts it all on the table and yet wants the kid to bear that burden. Ryan, of course, doesn’t fully understand what he’s being pulled into.
He is still a child who is trying to make his mark, particularly to the one adult whose opinion appears to count. So when Butcher questions him, it drives him directly to Homelander. And that choice brings one of the most sinister moments of the season.
Butcher’s War Against Homelander Might Cost Him, Ryan
The consequences are savage. Homelander does not hold back, and Ryan suffers. It is not merely a physical struggle, but a symbolic one of all that is fractured between them: father, son, legacy. When Butcher comes and sees Ryan barely alive, there is a glimpse of something real. Regret. Pain. Maybe even love. However, the awkward reality is that it does not make any difference.
In case you missed it: ‘The Boys’ Season 5 Might Finally Exploit Homelander’s Real Weakness
Kripke clarifies that although Butcher may be feeling bad, it will not stop him. If faced with the same choice again, he’d make it again. “If he has the virus and needs Ryan to do it again, he would do it without hesitation. He’d feel bad, but I don’t think that would stop any of his actions. Which is, of course, what matters,” he explained.
That is what he has become now, a man so obsessed with his mission that even the only person he loves is disposable. And that’s what makes this storyline hit so hard. It’s not just about whether Ryan survives. It’s about what there is left of Butcher if he doesn’t. Since at this stage, winning does not resemble justice anymore. It just looks like a loss.
You might like to read: ‘The Boys’ Season 5 Is Turning Butcher Into the Monster He Hates
