Few arguments in comic book culture refuse to die quite like Batman versus Superman. Power, brains, training, and fans have been up and down on it all. However, now, with the help of Robert Pattinson, the discussion has taken another twist: who is the more important hero?
And that is a far messier question, indeed.
Robert Pattinson’s Bold Batman Claim Highlights DC’s Biggest Divide
Recently, Pattinson, who will reappear in ‘The Batman Part II’, called Batman the most relevant and important superhero. It is a daring claim, and not one that is going to rest well with Superman enthusiasts. He called Batman “the granddaddy of superheroes and the most relevant and important.”
Related: What Happened After ‘House of the Dragon’ Is Why Milly Alcock Isn’t Afraid of ‘Supergirl’ Backlash
“Since I started doing the part, you look into the kind of legacy of it,” Pattinson explained. “There’s something about that face that’s a very deep and primal thing. It connects to people, it connects to children, it connects to adults, and then the legacy of the movies as well.” Fair enough, Batman is an appealing character.
He is down-to-earth, imperfect, and relatable. There’s something raw about a man with no powers standing toe-to-toe with gods. That “anyone could be him” energy is powerful. But here’s where the debate gets interesting. Superman is not only about power, but about identity.
A stranger who grew up in a small town, struggling to find his place in the world with the burden of being different. That is no less relatable, just in an entirely different sense. Batman mirrors human pain, whereas Superman mirrors human hope. When we speak of relevance, we are speaking of perspective. Others relate better to struggle. Others relate to purpose. Nor is either side in the wrong.
The Real Difference Shows On Screen
The one area where Pattinson hits the nail on the head is in the film track record. Batman has always been a big-screen success, with Michael Keaton and Christian Bale each making a unique impression. The path of Superman has been. less steady. Standout performances such as those of Christopher Reeve and Henry Cavill have been made, yet the overall direction has been inconsistent.
In case you missed it: How DC’s Supergirl Adds A Dark Twist To Her First Meeting With Superman With One Major Change
Even crossover efforts like ‘Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice’ were met with more division than unity. That inconsistency matters. It influences the perception of the audience towards these characters in the long run.
Still, it is a mistake to declare one of them as more definitive. Batman is a creature of the dark. So, Superman is supposed to be a creature of the light. They are not competing concepts; they are complementary ones. And perhaps that is why this debate is never-ending.
You might also like to read: Milly Alcock Says Supergirl Should Teach Girls It’s OK To Be “Bad And Messy”
