For decades, the gothic, deadpan youth image had remained absolutely unchallenged. Actress Christina Ricci‘s performance as Wednesday Addams in the 1991 comedy/horror ‘The Addams Family’ remains an absolute masterpiece in the history of pop culture.
However, Netflix’s sensational ‘Wednesday‘ has put an end to this gothic monopoly once and for all. Jenna Ortega’s version of the popular character took the internet by storm and even sparked a heated debate among fans of different generations. The burning question remains: whose portrayal of the dark character is better? Let’s dive in.
How Wednesday Addams’ Persona Grew Over The Years
To understand the foundations of these competing aesthetics, let’s recall the darkly comedic atmosphere of the 1990s. In the movies ‘The Addams Family’ (1991) and ‘Addams Family Values’ (1993), Christina Ricci established herself as the ultimate Wednesday Addams.
Her Wednesday was the evil genius plotting to throw her baby brother off the roof of the family’s mansion, torturing her counselors at the summer camp, and burning down the stage for the Thanksgiving play.
Wednesday’s malevolent character thrived on the contradiction—she was the tiny, pigtailed girl with the wicked mind of a professional hitman.
Related: ‘Wednesday’ Actor Jenna Ortega Was Ready to Walk Away From Acting But One Role Changed It All
The actress’s interpretation relied on a subtle, dead-eyed charisma, earning worldwide cult recognition. It was felt in her flat tone of voice, forced smiles, and laughter caused by her position in the brightly lit world of happiness that she hated passionately.
Meanwhile, Jenna Ortega, who played the character many decades later, faced an entirely fresh challenge. Unlike Ricci’s Wednesday, Ortega’s version had to be more than the source of dark humor.
She had to be the main character of the story and the center of its mysterious events.
Thus, Ortega was supposed to create a complex character who could solve the murder case and handle teenage drama. Ortega gave a series of outstanding performances in ‘Wednesday’ (2022), adding her own flavor to the gothic iconography.
Moreover, her refusal to blink and her viral dance performance earned her critical acclaim and several nominations at the Emmys, Golden Globes, and SAG Awards.
Ortega’s Wednesday is a highly intelligent and fiercely protective outsider who uses sarcasm and emotional distance as the only tools in the supernatural chaos.
What Sets The Two Versions Apart?
These fundamental differences between a villainous child and a detective teenager define the core division among fans. Ricci’s Wednesday is an unfiltered, darkly humorous portrayal of a sociopathic child.
On the other hand, Ortega’s character is sophisticated and distinctly modern. The new Wednesday is not only a detective but also a musician who can solve murders and communicate with her peers.
Still, some fans argue that the supernatural school setting, full of monsters, strips her of her uniqueness, making her just another goth alternative teenager.
In case you missed it: All Actresses Who Have Played Wednesday Addams
It is important to mention that this series does not support any of these fan interpretations or choose a definitive winner. Quite the contrary, Netflix cast Ricci in their show, a perfect example of meta-casting.
The actress appears in several episodes as the charming botany teacher at Nevermore Academy. The audience appreciated this casting choice, as they finally got to watch two goth queens in action.
Ortega’s incredible success can be seen as a gift from Ricci, as the actress has paved the way for Wednesday’s evolution.
In conclusion, deciding which actress is better at portraying Wednesday is a matter of personal preference. A darkly humorous portrayal is apt for Ricci’s interpretation.
But a sophisticated and modern character played by Ortega will appeal to those who love complex characters. Nonetheless, both actresses proved that it takes a cold heart, a deadly look, and a disregard for rules to become a goth icon.
You might also like to read: ‘Wednesday’ Season 3 To Dive Deeper Into The Hyde Mythology As Netflix Expands The Addams Universe With New Spin-Off
