Albus Dumbledore, the wise and benevolent headmaster of Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, is often regarded as one of the most beloved characters in the ‘Harry Potter’ series. He is portrayed as a powerful wizard and a mentor to Harry Potter.
In addition, he is a symbol of hope and goodness in a world filled with darkness. However, as we delve deeper into the series, a more complex picture emerges, raising questions about Dumbledore’s true motives and actions. So, is Dumbledore a hero we should admire, or is there more villainy in him than we’d like to admit?
Dumbledore: A Complex Hero Or A Villain In Disguise?
From giving Harry his first Christmas gift to standing up to the Ministry of Magic, Dumbledore seemed like the ultimate protector. And, let’s not forget his legendary defeat of Gellert Grindelwald, a dark wizard whose ambitions rivaled Voldemort’s. However, even in these early moments of greatness, there are small hints that Dumbledore’s motivations might not be as pure as they seem.
Related: Was Dumbledore’s Decision To Reject Petunia’s Request To Join Hogwarts In ‘Harry Potter’ Harsh?
One of the most significant revelations about Dumbledore is his past relationship with Gellert Grindelwald. Gellert sought to establish a magical supremacy over the Muggle world.
Moreover, the movies imply that Dumbledore was once as passionate about this cause as Grindelwald. In the early books, Dumbledore is seen as an individual who mentors Harry. Additionally, it wasn’t until tragedy struck in the form of his sister Ariana’s death that Dumbledore turned away from these dangerous ambitions.
This was a very chilling revelation for readers. How did Dumbledore get so close to becoming a dark wizard himself? And if he could so easily embrace such dangerous ideals what else is he hiding? In addition, he has made many questionable decisions in his past, one of which was allowing Tom Riddle to become a Dark Wizard and manipulating Harry’s life for his own ends.
Dumbledore’s Relationship With Tom Riddle
Then there’s the question of Tom Riddle. Dumbledore recognized the dark potential in Riddle from the very beginning. He could see the danger in his eyes, the cruelty in his heart. And yet, Dumbledore chose to give him a place at Hogwarts, a chance to learn magic. A lot of people wonder if Dumbledore could have done more to steer Riddle away from becoming Lord Voldemort.
Related: How Many Actors Have Played Dumbledore In The ‘Harry Potter’ Franchise?
Additionally, many fans wonder why Dumbledore didn’t do more to stop Riddle’s rise to power. Instead of mentoring Riddle and guiding him away from his destructive path, Dumbledore neglected him. This allowed his dark impulses to fester. This neglect can be seen as a significant failure on Dumbledore’s part.
By not providing Riddle with the guidance and support he needed, Dumbledore inadvertently contributed to his transformation into Voldemort. Additionally, this raises questions about Dumbledore’s judgment and his ability to truly understand and help those in need.
Dumbledore’s Treatment Of Harry Potter
One of the most controversial aspects of Dumbledore’s character is his treatment of Harry. While he claims to be acting in Harry’s best interests, Dumbledore often puts Harry in dangerous situations without his consent. He manipulates Harry’s life. It can be said that he forced him to confront Voldemort at a young age.
Additionally, he was willing to sacrifice innocent lives to achieve his goal, and he often ignored the suffering of others in his pursuit of the greater good. He knew that Harry would have to die to defeat Voldemort, yet he kept this devastating truth hidden until the very end.
In case you missed it: ‘Harry Potter’ Actor Miriam Margolyes Wants Adult Fans To Move On From The Franchise
Was Dumbledore truly acting in Harry’s best interest, or was he treating him as just another piece on the chessboard? He placed a young boy in unimaginable danger time and time again, all to achieve his ultimate goal of defeating Voldemort. Is that what a true hero does?
Additionally, in the final book of the series, ‘Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows’, Dumbledore’s true nature is revealed. We learn that he has been manipulating Harry’s life from the beginning, using him as a weapon against Voldemort. At the end of the day, Dumbledore is a character filled with contradictions.
He’s a man who saved the wizarding world but also manipulated a child to do so. He fought for what was right, However, his past is tainted with darkness and ambition. He’s a hero, but one with deep flaws and questionable morality. Moreover, whether we see him as a hero or a villain depends on our own perspective and values.
