‘Stranger Things’ was the scariest when no one knew what was going on. That’s why the first season was so successful. It was a place that felt completely alien, and the characters were just as confused as the audience.
There was a monster, Will Byers was missing, and somehow Joyce could communicate with her son through Christmas lights. There were no rules known to anyone. And, come to think of it, it was all terrifying. The issue is that as ‘Stranger Things’ explained its world, it made it less frightening.
The Mystery Made The Upside Down Terrifying
Examine the opening scenes with the Demogorgon. As it emerges, it is still very little known. Nancy hears movement in the Byers house. Jonathan notices something in the woods that he can’t fathom. Later, the creature suddenly shows up at the Byers’ house and attacks Joyce and Jonathan.
Related: ‘Stranger Things’ Star Matthew Modine Believes Dr. Brenner Had a Mysterious Edge Nobody Saw Coming
These moments are so unsettling because the show doesn’t provide enough information. The Upside Down itself is even introduced almost like a nightmare. As Hopper passes through the gate of the Russian lab into the alternate Hawkins, it is shrouded in odd spores and decay. The town looks lifeless.
The show didn’t require a lengthy explanation of its ecosystem. It’s all in the picture. It’s the same situation with Will’s disappearance. His mother hears his voice through the walls, but she doesn’t know whether he is alive, dead, or somehow trapped somewhere else. Joyce’s frantic efforts to communicate with him are both emotional and unsettling because of that uncertainty.
Then there’s Eleven. In Season 1, even her powers are enigmatic. The squad doesn’t know where she got her powers from or why she knows so much about the strange creature that is hunting them. She seems to be a part of a large puzzle, one that is linked to the Upside Down. This feeling of discovery was a big element of the horror of the show.
Once Everything Had An Origin, The Fear Changed
But as the seasons went on, ‘Stranger Things’ began to offer answers. In Season 2, the Mind Flayer appeared as a much bigger intelligence controlling the creatures of the Upside Down. Season 3 turned the horror into a giant physical monster made from melted rats and possessed humans. Those scenes were still disturbing, but the unknown quality was fading away.
In Case You Missed It: Millie Bobby Brown Says ‘Stranger Things’ Co-Stars “Food-Shamed” Her Over Go-To British Lunch
Then Season 4 took it one step further and showed us the origins of Vecna. The fact that Henry Creel was One, and later Vecna, is interesting from a mythology standpoint. The confrontation with Eleven in the Upside Down gives the entire story a definite villain with a history, motive, and link to Hawkins.
But that also alters the perception of the previous seasons. The mysterious evil behind the Upside Down now has a face. Being understood is not necessarily a bad story; it’s just not as terrifying as the unknown. By Season 5, the characters enter that world with years of knowledge behind them. They know the creatures, understand the rules much better, and are actively hunting its biggest threat.
That progression makes sense for a final season, but it also highlights the central irony of ‘Stranger Things’: the more the characters learn about the monster, the less mysterious the monster becomes. The early scene of the Demogorgon prowling through the Byers’ house is more terrifying than the much larger monster battle later in the show.
Eventually, the show told us exactly what the nightmare was, and that made it all feel normal.
You Might Also Like To Read: ‘Stranger Things’ Star Explains Why Vecna’s Death Was More Tragic Than Fans Realized
