‘Little House on the Prairie’ is remembered as one of the most wholesome family dramas of all time. It is built on heartwarming stories, a comfort-watch that you can always return to.
But the series also never shied away from tackling surprisingly heavy subjects. From grief and loss to crime and addiction, here are the top 10 moments when ‘Little House on the Prairie’ got dark.
10. Young Laura’s Prayers
In the episode “The Lord Is My Shepherd“, we see the Ingalls family welcomes a baby boy. Things take a turn for the dark when young Laura becomes jealous of the attention he receives and asks God to take the baby away.
When the baby suddenly falls ill and dies, Laura becomes convinced that her thoughts caused the tragedy. Overwhelmed by guilt, she runs away and begs God to take her life away instead. The episode ends with her returning home, but it was one of the most traumatic events in the show.
Related: Melissa Gilbert Defends Netflix’s ‘Little House On The Prairie’ Amid Historical Accuracy Debate
9. Mary Finds Out She Is Blind
Mary Ingalls’ storyline in the show was truly unforgettable. Bright, ambitious and full of dreams for the future, Mary finds out about this devastating diagnosis. It was heartbreaking to see the moment she woke up in bed, opened her eyes and realised she could no longer see.
Her cries of anguish were difficult to forget. Fortunately, the plotline was only momentarily tragic as Mary gradually finds the strength to adapt and embrace her new reality, and work towards building a meaningful future.
8. Caroline Faces A Dangerous Infection
In the episode “A Matter of Faith”, Caroline Ingalls faces a terrifying ordeal when she stays at home to prepare pies for a church gathering, and Charles and the girls go away for the weekend.
She begins to suffer from dizzy spells and hallucinations and realises that a cut on her leg has become dangerously infected. With no one around to help and her condition rapidly worsening, Caroline is forced to perform a painful procedure on herself. We only get to see her heating a knife and preparing to drain the infection before the scene cuts away. It was very intense to watch.
7. Thomas Stark’s Rage
The episode “Rage” was a hard watch. We see a struggling farmer, Thomas Stark, losing everything and being denied a loan. He suffers a complete mental breakdown and kills his wife and daughter.
Fleeing from the authorities, he reaches the Wilder home where he mistakes Laura and Jenny for his family. He holds them at gunpoint and threatens to kill them. The episode was filled with tension as Laura and Jenny try to find a way to escape from this.
6. Albert’s Addiction
‘Little House on the Prairie’ ventured into more mature territory with Albert’s drug addiction. After hanging out with the wrong crowd while living in the city, Albert finds himself in a lot of trouble. Charles brings him back to Walnut Grove in hopes of giving him a fresh start.
Instead, he discovers Albert had become addicted to morphine. What follows is a painful journey as Albert fights to overcome the addiction. But the process was too violent and tragic to watch.
In Case You Missed It: The Biggest Differences Between Netflix’s ‘Little House On The Prairie’ And The Original
5. Ellen’s Death
In the episode “My Ellen”, we see Laura, Mary, and their friend Ellen go skinny-dipping in a lake. But when a group of boys approaches, they hide underwater until they leave. Tragically, Ellen never surfaces and drowns. Devastated by the loss, Laura blames herself.
Hoping to comfort Ellen’s mother, she visits her with flowers. The episode takes an even darker turn when the grief-stricken mother mistakes Laura for Ellen, lures her and traps her in the family’s cellar. As she prepares a birthday cake for the child she believes has returned, Charles desperately tries to find his missing daughter.
4. Mr Edwards Comes Back
“The Return of Mr Edwards” saw the beloved character’s return only for things to take a turn in the first few minutes of the episode. While working as a foreman of a logging company, a tree falls over Mr Edwards and nearly kills him.
The accident leaves him unable to walk, and we see such a warm character get consumed by anger and hopelessness. His depression deepens, and he even begins to contemplate suicide. Charles and Laura are left to do everything in their ability to restore his hope.
3. The Plague Comes To Walnut Grove
The episode “Plague” was one of the first times ‘Little House on the Prairie’ showed just how quickly it can go from wholesome to straight-up devastating. When a deadly typhus outbreak spreads across Walnut Grove, the community is struck by fear.
Desperate to contain the epidemic, they forcibly quarantine the sick inside the church. Panic and suspicion divide the community. Moreover, the episode doesn’t shy away from showing the harsh realities of a disease outbreak during that time period.
2. Caroline Visits Her Friend
When Caroline receives a letter from an old friend who is sick and pregnant, the episode “A Faraway Cry” takes the setting out of Walnut Grove and to an influenza-ridden mining camp. She finds her friend dying, who asks her to make sure her baby finds a good home, away from her husband, who didn’t even want the baby in the first place.
In the same episode, we see another couple losing their baby. Caroline and Dr Baker give them her friend’s baby. It was one of the numerous times the show handled the many pregnancy-related illnesses that existed in the 1800s and the abuse that pregnant women suffered at the hands of their husbands.
1. Sylvia’s Sexual Assault And Death
The darkest plotline in Little House on the Prairie was definitely Sylvia’s storyline. When a man attacks and sexually assaults 16-year-old Sylvia, she finds out that she is pregnant. The town starts to gossip, and even her own father blames her for the rape.
Albert and Sylvia plan to flee together, only to again be attacked by Sylvia’s rapist. She doesn’t survive this encounter and dies while pregnant in front of Albert and her own father.
You Might Also Like To Read: The Tragic True Story That ‘Little House on the Prairie’ Left Out
