In the history of movies, not many first films hit with the kind of nightmare force that David Lynch’s 1977 movie ‘Eraserhead‘ did. It takes you down into a dirty, industrial world with a mutant baby and a lady living inside a radiator. It became a huge hit at midnight screenings and a key piece of surrealist cinema.
But the road to making it did not start with a vision of a man with that wild hair. It started with a rejection. In a way, the film that would define a whole generation of filmmakers was an accident that came out of a failed pitch.
How A Bizarre Daydream Became ‘Eraserhead’ Script
Back in the early 1970s, David Lynch was a student on a scholarship at the American Film Institute’s Center for Advanced Film Studies. He was trained as a painter and wanted to bring his dark, strange visions to the screen.
His first idea was a script called ‘Gardenback,’ which came from one of his own paintings of a hunched-over figure with plants growing out of its back. The script was a surreal story about adultery and had a growing insect that stood for a man’s desire for his neighbor. He planned it as a 45-minute film, but the AFI said the abstract, non-linear story was too long and turned it down flat.
Related: Why David Lynch Could Never Get ‘Ronnie Rocket’ Made
That dead end pushed him toward a new, even stranger idea. Lynch had a daydream about a little boy taking a man’s head to a pencil factory. Out of that bizarre little thought, ‘Eraserhead‘ was born.
He gave the AFI a new 21-page script and told them it was a feature film, even though it was really short. The board had serious doubts, but they gave in because Dean Frank Daniel backed him completely. He famously said he would quit if they did not approve the project. So the accidental film got the green light, against all expectations.
The Brutal Five-Year Production of ‘Eraserhead’
What came next was years of struggle and hard work. With only a small grant, Lynch started filming in 1972, but the project ate up the next five years of his life. He lived on the sets, which were old stables that were no longer used, and he was always running out of money.
Friends kept the production going, like his childhood buddy Jack Fisk, who was the production designer, and Fisk’s wife, the actress Sissy Spacek. They gave their own money to help. Even the lead actor Jack Nance’s wife, Catherine Coulson, pitched in with her tips from waiting tables. Lynch himself delivered newspapers just to get by.
In case you missed it: 25 Movies That Are Like Fever Dreams
The movie’s creepy industrial sound was a whole project by itself. Lynch and sound designer Alan Splet spent almost a year in a soundproof studio building that thick, layered audio.
The now-famous baby prop, which Nance called “Spike,” was kept so secret that Lynch made the projectionist wear a blindfold while watching the daily footage, just to protect how they made the practical effects. After a test screening went badly, Lynch cut 20 minutes out and got it down to its final 89-minute length.
‘Eraserhead’ Found Its Audience and Caught Hollywood’s Attention
When ‘Eraserhead‘ finally came out in 1977, it was like a physical and emotional picture of Lynch’s own fears. This included a time when he lived in a rough Philadelphia neighborhood and his worries about becoming a father. But the dream-like, gross movie found its people. It got support from unexpected fans like filmmaker Stanley Kubrick and, most importantly, producer Mel Brooks.
Brooks, who famously called Lynch “Jimmy Stewart from Mars,” saw the film and took to its creator right away. He said, “You’re a mad man, I love you! You’re in!” That praise got Lynch hired to direct ‘The Elephant Man,’ which kicked off his Hollywood career.
So what started as the failure of a project called ‘Gardenback‘ ended up leading to the lucky creation of one of the most original movies ever made. The rejection forced Lynch to dig deeper and go darker, and by accident, he gave the world a surreal masterpiece that would define his whole career and influence filmmakers for decades after.
You might also want to read: Christopher Nolan Nearly Gave Up on This David Lynch Classic Before It Changed His Career
