An old description on Netflix‘s page for ‘Gone with the Wind‘ has stirred up fresh anger online after screenshots of it started spreading this week. The wording pulled the 1939 Civil War epic right back into the middle of an argument that’s been going on for years about how old Hollywood movies should be presented to today’s audiences.
The listing put it plainly: “A 1939 American Civil War epic known for its racism. To learn more about Black lives in America, search ‘Black Lives Matter.'” That text appeared on the film’s page on Netflix, even though the movie isn’t actually available to stream in the US right now. So the page is really just sitting there inactive rather than working as a real listing. Fox News reported that this description wasn’t new at all. It had apparently been up for years, but it only caught fire this week.
Elon Musk and Online Reaction to the Controversy
Once people noticed, the reaction spread fast. Conservative commentators and regular users alike passed the screenshot around, with some saying it was a sign of political messaging creeping into how streaming services label older films. Elon Musk jumped into the conversation too, replying to a post about the description with just three words: “Needs to change.” Others went even further. Turning Point Action’s Jack Posobiec told his followers to “Buy physical media.”
Related: Netflix’s ‘Little House on the Prairie’ Under Fire in Woke Slamming Debate Ahead of Season 2
People’s opinions on the Netflix wording split pretty much how you’d expect. Some commenters, as noted by an outlet, said the description gives useful context for modern viewers. Others said it was unfair to boil down such a huge film to just one part of its story. Some online users even called for people to cancel their Netflix subscriptions over it.
Gone with the Wind’s History with Streaming Platforms
This is just the newest round in a fight over ‘Gone with the Wind‘ that’s been simmering for decades, mostly over how the film romanticizes the pre-Civil War South. Back in June 2020, right after George Floyd’s death, HBO Max pulled the movie from its lineup for a while. That happened after screenwriter John Ridley, who won an Oscar for ‘12 Years a Slave,‘ wrote an op-ed in the Los Angeles Times arguing the film should come down because it glorified the antebellum South. HBO Max eventually brought it back, but added a historical introduction, saying at the time that ignoring the film’s problems “would be irresponsible.“
In case you missed it: Netflix Reunites ‘Stranger Things’ Stars Millie Bobby Brown and David Harbour in New Spy Drama
Other streaming services that still carry the film describe it very differently. HBO Max calls it “A strong-willed Southern belle struggles to save her beloved home and find love against the backdrop of the American Civil War and Reconstruction.” Hulu sums it up as “Classic tale of Scarlett O’Hara’s battle to save her beloved Tara and find love during the Civil War.”
Gone with the Wind’s Legacy and Ongoing Cultural Debate
Whatever people think of the current dispute, ‘Gone with the Wind‘ still holds a massive place in film history. Based on Margaret Mitchell’s 1936 novel, it won eight Academy Awards, including best picture at the 1940 ceremony. Hattie McDaniel, who played Mammy, became the first Black performer ever to win an Oscar for her role. Adjusted for inflation, it’s still the highest-grossing movie of all time.
The book has gone through its own version of this fight. In 2023, its publisher, Pan Macmillan, added a warning to new editions without changing the original text, saying the novel “includes problematic elements including the romanticization of a shocking era in our history and the horrors of slavery.”
As of Wednesday afternoon, the disputed description seems to have disappeared from Netflix’s page. The company still hasn’t explained where it came from or why it was taken down.
You might also want to read: Why Netflix Didn’t Bring Millie Bobby Brown Back As Eleven For New ‘Stranger Things’ Series
