There is something strangely toxic about the similarity we always see between ‘Friends’ Ross Geller and ‘How I Met Your Mother’s Ted Mosby. At first glance, they are from different worlds. One is a palaeontologist navigating New York in the ‘90s. While the other is an architect telling his children an unnecessarily long story.
But you don’t even need to look closely to spot the similarities that are hard to ignore. From their complicated relationships to their insecurities and increasingly questionable behaviour, Ted and Ross are cut from the same cloth.
Ross Geller And Ted Mosby Follow The Same Annoying Blueprint
The similarities between Ross and Ted start almost immediately. Both are older brothers to a younger sister, have complicated romantic relationships with someone in their friend group, and tend to go completely overboard in romantic relationships. Even their careers are strangely similar. They both get fired from their jobs to eventually turn to teaching at a university. And here both of them end up dating a student.
Related: Top 10 Times Ross Was The Worst On ‘Friends’
They are also the resident know-it-alls of their respective groups, constantly eager to prove that they are the smartest person in the room. And, perhaps most importantly, both cheat on their partners with the women who are considered their love interests. Even their love interests have a connection with the resident player of their respective friend groups, Joey and Barney.
But the biggest similarity might be their character development – or rather, character deterioration. When we first meet Ross, he is a recently divorced man who has just reunited with his lifelong crush and is too nervous to tell her how he feels. Meanwhile, Ted is a hopeless romantic who is trying to tell his children the story of how he met their mother. Initially, both have qualities that are easy to sympathise with. Over time, those qualities completely disappear. They just become so reminiscent of those obnoxious men you run into in real life every now and then.
They become increasingly needy in their relationship, constantly demanding attention and validation. All Ross does is guilt-trip Rachel when she prioritises her career, projecting his insecurities at the cost of crossing her boundaries and disrespecting her choices. Ted does the same with Robin, repeatedly pursuing her despite her rejection and trying to convince her that she should want marriage and children.
And then there is the whining. Ross’s very first appearance with that dreadful “Hi” was a warning for everything that follows. And only Ted can manage to turn his entire dating history into a 200-episode-long emotional monologue.
Ross and Ted’s Archetype Reveals A Very Difficult Reality In Television
It is these similarities that point towards a very uncomfortable sitcom archetype: the“nice guys”. Both Ross and Ted were presented to us as sensitive, romantic and intellectual alternatives to the traditionally confident, immature or irresponsible male characters. They were the men we were encouraged to root for, because underneath all their flaws, they were supposed to be the good ones. The kind of men young women were often taught to look for in real life.
In Case You Missed It: 7 Times ‘Friends’ Was Completely Wrong
But today that “nice guy” image is so hard to accept. All their behaviours that were supposed to be romantic are nothing but toxic. Their “nice” behaviours always came with an expectation. They treat rejection as an obstacle to overcome rather than a boundary to respect. Emotional vulnerability becomes a tool for guilt-tripping their partners, and jealousy is framed as love and care. Even their intellectualism only comes as another way of asserting their superiority over the people around them.
This is what makes Ross and Ted so fascinatingly similar. They are different characters but of the same sitcom fantasy – the ones who were desperately framed as the hero while repeatedly behaving like the biggest red flag in the room.
You Might Also Like To Read: ‘How I Met Your Mother’: Why Ted Mosby Is No Better Than Barney Stinson
