It’s still one of the most famous upsets in Oscar history. On March 20, 1952, the Academy voters made it clear which side of history they were on. They gave the Best Actor Oscar to Humphrey Bogart for ‘The African Queen‘.
The man everyone thought would win, a 27-year-old force of nature named Marlon Brando, sat in the audience in shock. His performance as Stanley Kowalski in ‘A Streetcar Named Desire‘ had completely changed screen acting. However, as Variety said at the time, the “oversight reigns as one of the most notorious Oscar snubs.”
Humphrey Bogart’s Famous “Potato” Critique
To get why Bogart won, you have to look past the politics and straight at the man himself. Bogart, the king of stoic cool, didn’t just dislike Brando’s acting. He hated everything it stood for. His criticism, saved in biographies and interviews, comes down to seven words: “Get the potato out of your mouth.”
Related: Humphrey Bogart Almost Returned for a ‘Casablanca’ Sequel That Never Happened
This wasn’t just about age. It was a battle between two different ways of thinking. Bogart came from the old school. He learned his lines perfectly, said them clearly, and wore a suit like armor. However, when Brando showed up in Hollywood, he wore a ripped sweatshirt. Bogart, ever the cynic, famously said, “I came out here with one suit and everybody said I looked like a bum. Twenty years later, Marlon Brando came out with only a sweatshirt and the town drooled over him. That shows how much Hollywood has progressed.“
But the clothes were a small thing compared to the noise. Bogart couldn’t understand a word Brando said. While filming ‘The Harder They Fall‘ in 1956, Bogart worked with Rod Steiger, another Actors’ Studio guy. That experience pushed Bogart over the edge. He went after the new method actors who cared more about real feelings than clear speech.
“These Actors Studio types—they mumble their lines,” Bogart complained. “I can’t hear their words. I miss the cues. This scratch-your-ass-and-mumble school of acting doesn’t please me.”
In the most famous insult of that era, Bogart gave his take on why Brando was so popular: “I think Marlon Brando is one of the best young actors in the business,” he said kindly. Then came the jab. “I think he’ll be great as soon as he gets that potato out of his mouth.“
Humphrey Bogart’s Grudge and Oscar Campaign
For all the anger, it wasn’t just jealousy. Bogart was smart enough to see the change coming. One time while visiting the set of Streetcar, he looked at the wild Brando and told a friend, “This guy—he’ll be doing Hamlet when the rest of us are selling potatoes.”
In case you missed it: The Only TV Role Humphrey Bogart Ever Took Came With One Big Condition
Funny enough, Bogart was right. Brando did play Julius Caesar, and yes, he mumbled through that too. The tension finally came to a head at the 1952 Oscars. Kim Hunter, who starred with Brando, later said Bogart worked hard to beat the newcomer. “Everybody thought that it was high time that Humphrey Bogart finally won,” Hunter said. Bogart hired a publicist and flooded the trade papers with ads, using the industry’s frustration with Brando’s distance to his advantage.
Who History Sided With in the End
Looking back, history has sided with Brando. His Stanley Kowalski changed movies forever. Bogart’s win for ‘The African Queen‘ is often seen as a “career achievement” award. But Bogart’s complaint never went away. For decades, critics have told method actors to speak up. In his 1997 book ‘Tough Without a Gun,’ Stefan Kanfer wrote that Bogart stood for a dying kind of “professionalism,” while Brando stood for “raw, untamed id.”
In the end, Bogart didn’t really lose. He was the face of masculinity for the 1940s, but deep down, he knew the guy in the torn T-shirt had stolen the future. He just wished the thief would speak clearly.
You might also want to read: The Real Reason Billy Wilder Didn’t Want Humphrey Bogart in ‘Sabrina’
