In 2001, Richard Kelly’s sci-fi movie ‘Donnie Darko‘ looked like it was headed straight for the trash heap of film history. It had a good script and a solid cast with Jake Gyllenhaal and Drew Barrymore, but its premiere at Sundance was a disaster.
People booed, and the film walked away without a distributor. It got so bad that the movie was about to be sold directly to the Starz cable network, which would have pretty much made it a forgotten footnote.
Donnie Darko’s Near Death Experience
The story was complicated and confusing, with time travel, a giant rabbit named Frank, and some heavy ideas about fear and love. Hollywood studios were scared of it. In a country still shaken by ‘Columbine‘, a dark movie about a troubled teenager felt like a huge risk.
Kelly later told The Ringer just how bad things got. Months after Sundance, he said, “there’s still no distribution deal. The songs had not been paid for. We were going to have to lose all the music. They were saying cut 30 minutes out of the movie. It was looking really grim.” Everyone involved was terrified the film would end up “to the straight-to-DVD wastebasket.”
How Christopher Nolan Saved ‘Donnie Darko’
That is when Christopher Nolan stepped in. Back then, Nolan was not the big-deal director he is today, but he had just made waves with ‘Memento‘, a movie that people also thought was “too cerebral” for regular audiences. Executive producer Aaron Ryder, who had worked on ‘Memento‘, set up a private screening of ‘Donnie Darko‘ for the folks at Newmarket Films. He made sure to invite Nolan and his wife and producing partner, Emma Thomas. Ryder later said, “It was a great screening. Because while the movie was, let’s call it flawed, there was also something so unbelievably captivating about it.”
In case you missed it: Christopher Nolan Broke His Own Rule to Convince David Bowie to Star in ‘The Prestige’
When the movie ended and the lights came back on, Nolan did not hesitate. He and Thomas looked at the Newmarket executives, Chris Ball and Will Tyrer, and nodded. According to Kelly, they basically told them, “‘You guys should distribute this.‘” Nolan’s opinion meant a lot. Because ‘Memento‘ had done well money-wise, Newmarket trusted what he had to say. Kelly explained, “The executive producer of Memento brought Donnie Darko into the screen for the Newmarket people, and he strategically invited Christopher and his wife to the screening. They raved about the movie to the Newmarket executives and convinced them to buy it.” That seal of approval was what saved the film from going straight to video.
The Countdown Timers and Drew Barrymore’s Push for Theatrical Release
But the fight was not over. Even after Newmarket bought the film, they still wanted to send it straight to home video instead of putting it in theaters. Kelly says Drew Barrymore stepped in and begged the studio for a cinema release.
However, it was Nolan’s early belief in the movie that gave it any chance at all. Kelly added, “Chris convinced Newmarket to buy it and once they had bought it, we were not going to let them get away with not giving it a theatrical release.”
Nolan and Thomas did not just give a thumbs up. They also came up with a simple but smart idea to help people follow the confusing story. They suggested adding countdown timers underneath the title cards. Kelly said, “Chris and his wife, it was their idea to put the parenthetical beneath the title cards.” That small change gave viewers a guide to keep up with the dense plot. Kelly later told NME how much that support meant to him. He said, “It’s a huge, important gift whenever you have the support of your fellow filmmakers. I would always do that for others if I could.”
The Legacy of ‘Donnie Darko’, Thanks to Nolan’s Belief
The movie finally got a limited release in theaters just a few days after Halloween in 2001. It bombed at first, partly because it was only shown on 58 screens and partly because of 9/11. The film’s plot involved a plane crash, and that hit too close to home for a lot of people. But ‘Donnie Darko‘ found its real audience on DVD, and it grew into a massive cult hit.
For Richard Kelly, Christopher Nolan was the reason his movie even had a shot. He admitted, “Christopher Nolan had a lot to do with that, in kind of saving my career.” Because Nolan believed in a messy, brilliant film, ‘Donnie Darko‘ was pulled from obscurity and went on to become one of the biggest cult classics of the 2000s.
You might also want to read: Why Christopher Nolan Spent Years Trying to Cast Leonardo DiCaprio in ‘Inception’
