Kay Adams’ storyline in ‘The Godfather: Part II‘ wasn’t always written the way audiences saw it on screen. After giving birth to Anthony Vito Corleone and Mary Corleone, the original script showed her later pregnancy ending in a miscarriage. But a major change during production turned it into an abortion.
The decision essentially made the scene far more intense and had a much stronger impact on Michael Corleone’s story. The best part is that the suggestion for this change came from a cast member.
Why Kay’s Story Was Changed In ‘The Godfather: Part II’
Between ‘The Godfather‘ and its sequel, Michael Corleone goes through a tragic transformation. He starts as a college-educated war hero and becomes a mafia don over time.
A crucial part of this journey comes when Kay Adams-Corleone reveals that she ended her pregnancy rather than bringing another son into the violent world of the Corleones.
Related: 30 Best Gangster And Mob Movies Of All Time
Initially imagined as a miscarriage, it would’ve lessened the force of the characters’ emotions. The abortion twist showed us the couple reflecting on it as a troubling sign for their marriage. Of course, they were volatile and raised concerns about plunging another innocent life into the darkness.
During a panel at the 2017 Tribeca Film Festival, director Francis Ford Coppola explained how the change came about. His sister, Talia Shire, suggested the stronger idea, which changed the entire direction of the scene.
Shire, who played Connie Corleone in the franchise, believed that turning the miscarriage into an abortion gave Kay greater control over her role in the Corleone saga. She made a clear and bold decision not to play into their suffocating “traditional” values any longer. Well, Kay always had a mind of her own, and even when she let her heart follow Michael, she knew what she wanted out of motherhood.
How The Abortion Revelation Changed Michael Forever
Kay’s action in ‘The Godfather: Part II‘ directly responded to the pain Michael had caused within the family. Kay chose not to bring another child into his world, and as a result, the conflict between them became much more personal and intense.
In case you missed it: The Real Reason Why Vic Damone Was Too Scared To Star In ‘The Godfather’
Furthermore, the unborn child would have been their third, just like Michael was the third child of his parents, Vito and Carmela. Because of this, Kay’s decision can be seen as a rejection of Michael’s legacy.
The emotional impact becomes clear in the confrontation scene, where Kay says, “Michael, you are blind. It wasn’t a miscarriage. It was an abortion. An abortion, Michael. Just like our marriage is an abortion. Something that’s unholy and evil.”
She admits he could “never forgive” her. Moreover, according to the beliefs of the Catholic Church and the Sicilian mafia code, her action is treated as equal to killing a male heir, which makes the situation even more serious.
As the scene continues, Michael moves further away from the values of his father, Vito Corleone. He stops acting like a family man and becomes more ruthless, even towards his own family. Finally, the confrontation ends in violence when Michael attacks Kay, which brings their marriage to an end.
You might also like to read: Robert De Niro Once Rejected A Totally Different Role In ‘The Godfather’ And It Was The Best Career Decision
