There are a lot of devastating moments on TV, but not many stick with you like the death of Jane Margolis. She was the tattoo artist with the Bettie Page bangs and a heart as fragile as her sobriety.
In Season 2 of ‘Breaking Bad,’ she choked to death on her own vomit while Walter White just stood there and watched. It was brutal and unforgivable, and you never really forget it.
Vince Gilligan Originally Planned to Keep Jane Alive
But here is something fans don’t know. Jane was supposed to live. As per reports, Vince Gilligan, the creator, and his writers originally planned to keep Jane around much longer. Krysten Ritter’s performance was so good that it won over the whole writers’ room. Early on, they talked about sending Jesse and Jane to rehab together, allowing their relationship to evolve into a genuine redemption arc.
Related: How ‘Breaking Bad’ Convinced Nicolas Cage to Finally Embrace Television After 45 Years in Hollywood
It would have been the hopeful path, the one where two broken people fix each other, but they didn’t take it.
Why the Writers Chose Tragedy Over a Jesse Redemption Arc
The real reason cuts straight to the heart of why ‘Breaking Bad‘ is a tragedy and not a romance. The writers felt that Jane was giving Jesse too much stability too early. At a time when Jesse was supposed to be falling apart, he had found someone who actually loved him. Someone who saw past the “Cap’n Cook” act to the wounded kid underneath.
In case you missed it: ‘Breaking Bad’ Creator Vince Gilligan Reveals Wild Donald Trump Twist for Saul Goodman’s Fate
That stability, the writers thought, was dangerous for the story. Jesse needed to hit rock bottom before he could even think about getting back up. And he sure did fall.
How Jane’s Death Destroyed Jesse Pinkman and Changed the Show Forever
What came after Jane’s death is still some of the hardest TV to watch. Jesse went on a heroin binge that almost killed him. He spent weeks calling Jane’s voicemail just to hear her voice. The pain followed him for seasons before it finally boiled over in one of the show’s most brutal moments. In the episode ‘Ozymandias,’ Walt admits he could have saved her but chose not to.
The damage didn’t stop with Jesse. Jane’s father, Donald, was an air traffic controller who fell apart from grief. He ended up causing the Wayfarer 515 disaster that killed 167 people. All of that because one man did nothing, and it almost got even darker. Gilligan thought about an alternate version where Walt injects Jane with heroin himself. He would have killed her directly instead of just letting her die.
However, the writers voted it down. As one person close to the show put it, “He wasn’t there yet in his criminal journey.” The quiet horror of Walt doing nothing turned out to be more powerful and more damning.
Bryan Cranston, who played Walt, has said the scene broke him as a person. While filming Jane’s death, he suddenly saw his own daughter’s face instead of Krysten Ritter’s. He later said, “I saw my real child choking to death, and it scared me.” That real fear stayed with him long after they stopped filming.
Why Killing Jane Was the Only Choice That Made ‘Breaking Bad’ a Masterpiece
Looking back, killing Jane instead of saving her was the only choice that could have made ‘Breaking Bad‘ what it became. Jesse’s whole sad story, his time working with Gus, his moral awakening, and the months he spent locked up by Jack Welker’s gang, all of it comes from that one moment of loss.
Would Jesse have ever gotten free from Walt if Jane had lived? Probably not. He would have had something to lose and Walt would have used it against him.
In the end, Gilligan and his team picked the story over the romance. Jane Margolis died so ‘Breaking Bad‘ could live. And nearly 15 years later, we are still not over it. Krysten Ritter went on to star as Jessica Jones, but for ‘Breaking Bad‘ fans, she will always be the girl who almost made it out; the one whose death broke Jesse Pinkman for good.
You might also want to read: The Real Reason Walter White Became Heisenberg Changes How Fans See ‘Breaking Bad’
