‘The Boys’ is known for subverting conventional superhero tropes. Instead of clear-cut heroes and villains, the series thrives on morally ambiguous, deeply flawed characters, and that’s what makes it feel so refreshing compared to other superhero stories.
Over the years, we’ve seen plenty of unforgettable morally gray characters in the show. But some never received the attention, development, or endings they truly deserved. These are the 10 ‘The Boys‘ characters who deserved better.
10. Madelyn Stillwell
Instead of becoming a scapegoat for a monster she once helped control, Madelyn Stillwell deserved far better. As a Vought executive, she was calm, calculating, and exceptionally skilled at weaponizing Supes to serve the company’s interests.
We all know Madelyn was undeniably cruel and guilty of countless things. But between caring for her baby and constantly manipulating Homelander, her brutal death still came as a shock. At the very least, she deserved the chance to face the consequences of her actions, and perhaps even seek redemption.
Related: MM’s Dark Mindset In ‘The Boys’ Season 5 Is A Major Red Flag
9. Kimiko Miyashiro
Karen Fukuhara’s brilliant portrayal of Kimiko Miyashiro deserved the chance to shine on its own terms. We needed to see her fully become Kimiko instead of constantly being reduced to “The Female.”
Kimiko had all the potential to step out of the sidelines and take center stage as one of the show’s most compelling characters. ‘The Boys‘ had the perfect opportunity to explore her past, confront her trauma, and give her a more meaningful journey of healing and redemption, but it never fully delivered.
8. Queen Maeve
Much like the other self-aware members of the Vought machine, Queen Maeve spent years standing by as Homelander carried out one cruelty after another. But when she reconnected with her long-lost love and finally joined forces with the Boys, we caught a glimpse of the idealistic hero she once was.
Maeve embodied compassion and true heroism, but years in The Seven slowly reshaped her into little more than a marketable symbol. While her fate was never fully confirmed, the last time we saw her, she walked away in search of peace after sacrificing everything to take down Soldier Boy. Maybe obscurity was what she wanted, but for us fans, her arc still feels incomplete.
7. Blindspot
After Translucent’s death, Blindspot was introduced as a potential new member of The Seven. Young, eager, and genuinely hopeful about becoming a hero, he admired Homelander and was visibly starstruck when he finally met him.
But instead of meeting the hero he had idolized, Blindspot was immediately subjected to Homelander’s violent streak simply because he viewed him as weak and unworthy. In a single brutal moment, his dreams were destroyed. Blindspot only wanted to help people, yet he became another victim of Vought’s toxic obsession with power and image.
6. Hugh Campbell Sr.
Hugh Campbell Sr. deserved calm, not an ending filled with horror, violence, and guilt. Throughout his life, he did everything he could to care for Hughie and protect him, only to get dragged into the terrifying world of superheroes in the end.
In his final moments, Hughie briefly considers injecting him with Compound V, but ultimately realizes his father deserved a dignified death instead. His mom, Daphne, however, makes the decision for him and injects Hugh Sr. with V without hesitation. What follows is heartbreaking: Hughie is forced to euthanize his own father after the Compound turns him into something unrecognizable, giving one of the show’s few genuinely good-hearted characters a fate he never deserved.
In Case You Missed It: ‘The Boys’: The Hidden Truth About Homelander’s Mother Makes His Story Even More Tragic
5. Black Noir
Brilliantly portrayed by Nathan Mitchell, Black Noir deserved far more exploration. As the most mysterious member of The Seven, he constantly intrigued viewers, and his exceptional combat skills only made us want to know more about him. Throughout the series, there were repeated hints that a far more layered character existed beneath the silence.
The secrecy surrounding his past only heightened the desire to see Black Noir finally step into the spotlight. He had the potential for one of the show’s most compelling character arcs, especially with his history with Soldier Boy and his desire for revenge. Instead, his story ended far too abruptly for a character with so much untapped potential.
4. Kenji Miyashiro
Abducted as a child, Kenji Miyashiro’s life was defined by trauma. His bond with his sister, Kimiko Miyashiro, remained the only piece of humanity he had left, and the two became each other’s entire support system.
Kenji never truly had the chance at a normal or peaceful life. Just as he finally reunited with Kimiko, he was killed while trying to protect her. A character with so much emotional depth and potential was ultimately reduced to nothing more than a “supe terrorist” in the eyes of the world.
3. Supersonic
He quickly became a fan-favorite Supe thanks to his polite, easygoing personality and his surprisingly adorable singing and dancing skills. And once we learned about his friendship with Starlight, it became impossible not to root for him.
Even after Starlight warned him about joining The Seven, Supersonic still chose to help her in secret. He had the potential to become one of her greatest allies in exposing Vought and Homelander. Instead, his loyalty tragically backfired, leading to one of the show’s most brutal and heartbreaking deaths.
2. Robin Ward
Though the pilot episode of ‘The Boys‘ remains phenomenal, Robin Ward’s death was genuinely heartbreaking. In the opening scene, Robin is standing on the sidewalk with her boyfriend, Hughie, when A-Train—high and completely reckless—runs straight through her at super speed.
All that remains are her bloodied hands still clinging to Hughie. The moment instantly introduced viewers to the brutal and horrifying world of the show. But what makes Robin’s death even more tragic is how avoidable and senseless it was. Her entire future was snuffed out due to a freak accident.
1. Becca Butcher
Becca Butcher was living a peaceful, ordinary life with her husband Billy Butcher while quietly working at Vought International until she suddenly disappeared without a trace. Only later did we learn about the horrific experiences she had endured.
As if Homelander’s sexual assault was not enough, Becca was forced to abandon her entire life and live in hiding under Vought’s control while raising Ryan, Homelander’s son. And when Homelander eventually discovered them, he once again brought fear and chaos into her life. Just as there seemed to be hope that she and Butcher might finally reunite, Becca was accidentally killed by Ryan. She deserved a shot at having her happy family back.
You Might Also Like To Read: 10 Hilariously Savage Satirical TV Shows
